Assessed property values in Allegheny County are significantly out of step with the real estate market, leaving some property owners paying much higher effective tax rates than others — a violation of the Pennsylvania constitution’s requirement that taxes be “uniform.” This is what a Court of Common Pleas judge will be forced to conclude based on the clear evidence in the Pittsburgh Public School District’s lawsuit, leading to the county’s first full reassessment in over a dozen years.

Meanwhile, a new filing in an ongoing assessment appeal repeats allegations that official county real estate data, which determines key metrics like the common level ratio (CLR) and coefficient of dispersion (COD), had been manipulated to inflate tax revenues and to make the assessment system look better than it is.

At least as importantly, however, the filing sheds light on the insufficiency of state and county laws and regulations to prevent this kind of manipulation. County Council must add those safeguards to restore confidence in the system to to prevent future malfeasance.

Ratios and coefficients

By now, many will be familiar with the CLR, which is a percentage applied to the market value of the property, on appeal by either the property owner or a taxing body, to determine its assessed value. The CLR goes down when the real estate market goes up in order to keep assessed values roughly compatible with the last full-county reassessment — in this case, in 2012.

Advertise with us

But over time, as communities within Allegheny County experience different levels of market growth (or decline), the spread of assessed values among similar properties tends to increase. This spread is measured by another acronym, the COD, which describes the average variation of property values from the median for that class.

The International Association of Assessing Officers considers COD figures between 5% and 15% to describe normal variation, while anything beyond that describes an unfair distribution of the tax burden — usually in favor of people with more valuable real estate, who pay less as percentage of their property’s fair market value. In recent years, Allegheny County’s official COD has hovered around 20%.

One year is particularly interesting: 2020. The official COD that year was 20.2%, but an independent study by the University of Chicago, as reported in the PPS lawsuit, calculated a much higher figure, 24.5%. This means that the spread in the state’s analysis of the county’s submitted data was much lower than the spread in an independent analysis of public data, making the system look fairer than it is. How is this possible?

‘Cooking the books’

All the statistics used in analyzing and determining assessed values are calculated by the State Tax Equalization Board (STEB), whose purpose is to ensure the uniformity of property taxation. But there are two relevant facts that limit its effectiveness. First, it makes its calculations based entirely on real estate sales data. Second, counties have significant discretion over which sales they report to STEB.

This means counties can strategically exclude sales from their STEB data dumps to manipulate figures like the CLR and COD. Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg famously stated in his decision invalidating the 2022 CLR that the county had been “cooking the books” to keep the ratio (and therefore taxing bodies’ revenues) artificially high. County officials admitted the numbers it gave STEB were bad, but chalked it up to a “mistake.”

Advertise with us

The Office of Property Assessments applies codes to real estate transactions to ensure unusual ones — say, transferring a house to a family member for almost no cost — don’t mess with the data. But there’s no oversight or accountability for the coding process. Excluding inconvenient data, resulting in high CLRs and low CODs, can make the assessment system look more stable than it really is.

A new filing on behalf of two Pittsburgh homeowners, which seeks to invalidate even the newly adjusted CLRs as wrongly inflated, points out “there are no statutes or state agency regulations or County Ordinances or policies for an independent review or audit of the appropriateness of either (a) the personnel doing sales coding or (b) the resources or methods used for sales coding or of the sales coding.”

Further, “the coding of sales is not transparent because the codes that the county assigns to sales and transmits to STEB are not published by the County on any of its real estate websites.” In fact, thousands of excluded transactions every year are simply labeled “other.”

Crime and punishment

At-large County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam generated headlines in mid-April when she introduced legislation that would automatically trigger a countywide reassessment when the coefficient of dispersion cracks 15%. This isn’t a bad idea, though ultimately regular statewide reassessments are the only sustainable solution.

Within the bill, however, are some details that should be passed into law regardless: 1) The assessment office would have to engage an independent firm to check its ratios, and to make the results public; 2) a Chief Assessment Officer who submits false information to STEB would be unable to be reappointed to the office, or to any other county office, ever; and 3) a CAO who intentionally manipulates, or allows to be manipulated, real estate data would incur a $500 fine for each instance.

Advertise with us

Ms. Hallam sees the problem with clear eyes. Even if there’s no appetite on council for regular reassessments, there should be for these commonsense reforms.

Because no property assessment system will be stable and trustworthy until the system’s foundation — the data itself — is secure.

Correction: The original version of this editorial misstated the nature of a filing in Allegheny County courts. It is a new filing made in an ongoing appeal, not a new lawsuit.