Energize Pittsburgh, a new pilot program to offset energy burdens for high-need residents, is a great way to reduce costs and increase efficiency — enhancing economic justice and curbing climate change all at once. But despite the Gainey administration’s splashy rollout, there’s nothing new about the idea: In fact, Mr. Gainey had already nixed a similar concept from the city’s original plan for federal American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds.
The Energize program, targeted to help vulnerable homeowners with high utility costs, will install solar panels, weatherize homes and replace gas fixtures with electric ones in exchange for tax credits. The end goals are grand: 100 upgraded homes by 2025, and 10,000 improved residences by 2030 — prioritizing low-income homeowners who desperately need the cost savings most.
The Gainey administration says it will use money from the Inflation Reduction Act, the 2022 economic incentive package for domestic manufacturing and clean energy. But statements from the city don’t say which of the roughly 20 clean energy programs will be used, instead vaguely referring to “incentives from the IRA” and its $4 billion budget. That’s not good enough.
After all, the city once planned to use a different, more stable, pot of money for the program: the 2021 American Rescue Plan Act, which flushed the city with $335 million to be spent ASAP. Back then, the city budgeted ARPA funds for a $10 million “homeownership utilities program” that would help struggling homeowners “weatherize, lower utility bills and promote renewable energy uses.” Mr. Gainey raided $6 million from that proposed appropriation in 2022, and removed it entirely in 2023.
One reason this matters is deadlines. ARPA funds must be allocated by Dec. 31, 2024, and spent by Dec. 31, 2026. By moving Energize Pittsburgh from ARPA to the IRA, the city is giving up the ability to quickly spend what once amounted to a $10 million dollar program to improve homes.
The city has struggled with the logistics problem of distributing ARPA funds for years. There have been some high-profile missteps, like a $2 million dollar relief program for local artists that actually went to fireworks and event staging. Another $10 million in ARPA money ostensibly for the city’s Reaching Out On The Streets (ROOTS) street health care centers never went to its intended purpose. And tens of millions set aside for capital improvements to essential amenities, like recreation centers, remain unspent.
Why would the city scrap a planned utility program from a pot of must-spend federal money, and instead move to a much more vague tax incentive program? (Don’t bother asking the administration: They don’t answer anyone’s questions, and not just the Post-Gazette’s.) The simplest answer is that reinventing the wheel was a way to avoid giving credit to the inventor of the original wheel: the previous mayor.
Whatever the reason, we hope the program is a success: It just didn’t have to take this long to come to fruition, or be this complicated.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.