After nearly six months of warnings from the Post-Gazette Editorial Board and, in recent weeks, from City Controller Rachael Heisler, both Mayor Ed Gainey and City Council are beginning at least to look like they are taking the city’s fragile finances seriously. But we’ll know if they are finally ready to make hard decisions once they take real action to rein in the city’s budget.
That will mean more than cobbling together a “task force” of the very people who were supposed to keep this crisis from happening in the first place. It means reopening the 2024 operating budget to adjust for clearly, even fraudulently unrealistic revenue projections, both for this year and for the four years after that. In turn, that means replacing false spending promises with honest figures — which will likely have to include staff cutbacks.
Until now, the Gainey administration’s attitude toward the budget seems to have been to hope no one would notice its fantasy-land arithmetic. But both the city newspaper and the City Controller have done their jobs to hold the administration accountable. Now the people with direct power over the budget — council and the Mayor himself — must do their jobs and fix it.
Just the facts
Last Friday, Mr. Gainey announced the formation of a “joint task force on city finances” — one day after the Post-Gazette newsroom, which functions independently of the Editorial Board, submitted questions for a substantial investigation into the city’s finances. That investigation was published on Sunday, and revealed based on documents from the Controller’s Office that the City of Pittsburgh is likely to plow through its entire (currently healthy) reserves in 2025 or 2026.
“We know that our residents have a lot of concerns about the state of our city finances,” Mr. Gainey said in announcing the task force. That is true — and it’s true in spite of his administration’s attempts to conceal that financial reality from Pittsburgh residents. The city’s operating budget is designed to look stable to the untrained eye, and only on close inspection do its serious flaws become apparent.
Among those flaws, the brazen underestimation of expenses for new union contracts has already resulted in $11 million being chipped off reserves over the next five years — and there’s more to come. Further, predictable declines in real estate tax receipts, as well as refunds, are piling up, even though they weren’t accounted for in the budget.
And then there’s the downright fraudulent projection that historically high annual interest income of $16 million will continue for the next five years, even as the city draws down its reserves (including federal ARPA funds) and rates likely decline. Finally, the so-called “jock tax” is still included in the budget, despite being invalidated by multiple courts.
Altogether, according to the Controller’s documents, there are between $140 million and $190 million in unlikely or impossible revenues in Mr. Gainey’s budget projections over the next five years. And those figures, we at the Editorial Board believe, may still be conservative.
Task force or day job?
The task force itself, meanwhile, fails to instill confidence the administration is taking the problem seriously. Its membership consists largely of the Mayor’s already-existing budget bureaucracy: Director of the Office of Management and Budget Jake Pawlak, Chief Financial Officer Patrick Cornell, Finance Director Jennifer Gula.
In other words, Mr. Gainey is assigning the task of assuring the stability of the city’s finances to the very people whose job it is to assure the stability of the city’s finances. This isn’t a task force; it’s a Monday.
If Mr. Gainey were truly concerned about Pittsburgh’s finances, he wouldn’t ask the people who designed them to fix them. If a bridge goes wobbly, you don’t rely entirely on the engineers who designed and built it to tell you what’s wrong with it: You get another expert who isn’t wedded to the original plans, and who can bring a fresh perspective.
There are two other officials invited to join the task force — Ms. Heisler and City Council Law and Finance Chair Erika Strassburger — who provide a veneer of objectivity to the enterprise, but they will be a minority whose influence on the task force’s “consensus report” can be easily limited. Indeed, both officials should be wary that the purpose here is to attach their names (and reputations) on a faulty bill of good fiscal health.
Blowing smoke
Altogether, the task force raises more questions than it answers. Above all: If the city’s finances are as good as the administration has insisted, why is it needed at all?
The mixed signals persist in the press release itself, with the Mayor’s Office describing collecting 39.2% of projected revenues in the first quarter of 2024 as “robust.” But last year, according to Finance Department documents, the city collected over 41% of projected revenues in the first quarter — when the vast majority of property taxes come in — which led to end-of-year tax results 5%, or about $25 million, less than budgeted. This year’s “robust” collections bode worse.
The truth is, the city’s budget does need to be reopened — less than four months after it was improvidently approved by City Council — and not just tweaked but overhauled. The document is a smokescreen designed to forestall the necessity of either austerity or tax increases. And the task force is, in all likelihood, just blowing more smoke.
But it is also an opportunity, before it’s too late, to take stock and to reverse course. It will test both the fortitude and the political acumen of Ms. Strassburger and Ms. Heisler. And it will test, once again, where the Gainey administration’s priorities really are.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.