Pittsburgh City Council’s latest foray into addressing record-high levels of homelessness is encouragingly creative and forward-thinking — but, as always, success or failure will depend on the details.
At Tuesday’s Planning Commission meeting, unlikely City Council duo Anthony Coghill and Deb Gross presented a plan for clusters of fully-outfitted tiny homes spread around the city. With an on-site staff person, portable restrooms, garbage collection, electricity and water, these little homes would offer much more privacy and stability than a typical congregate shelter.
It’s a concept that has been successful in dozens of cities across the country. But success is not automatic.
Most importantly, a tiny house scheme will only work with deep city-county cooperation. That means, first of all, city and county officials deciding who, exactly, the tiny homes are meant to house, so they can develop a joint strategy to make it work.
If the plan is to simply move people currently living in tent encampments to tiny homes, it will likely fail. Those who have shivered through the winter outside are generally among the most complicated social services cases: Moving them from tents to tiny houses won’t change that, and the problems that plague the encampments, including uncontrolled drug use, will follow them.
A more complete strategy, but one more difficult to execute, would be to offer the tiny houses to the residents of area shelters who have demonstrated the most independence, and who are already living in single-room occupancy (SRO) facilities. This would open up more SRO space in the shelters for eligible residents, which would in turn open more space for regular overnight guests.
Thinking of tiny homes as part of a dynamic, coordinated system — not as a simple solution — is the only way it will work.
To their credit, the councilors made it clear that this is a single piece a larger homelessness strategy. Ideally, the city would build more of what’s already worked: low-barrier facilities with SRO options like Second Avenue Commons. The original facility, borne out of six years of public-private planning at a cost of $22 million, was already overburdened at its opening. But launching another in a timely manner is impossible.
The appeal of the tiny homes, meanwhile, is in how quickly and inexpensively they can be constructed. Mr. Coghill, a contractor, built a prototype in a matter of days along Broadway Ave in Beechview. The city already owns 17,000 vacant lots, and these home clusters don’t require a large footprint. And besides providing the property and utility services, and handling the RFP, the city doesn’t foresee footing the bill: The same foundations that built Second Avenue Commons, plus the county, should chip in.
A tiny village would provide shelter and 24/7 services for around $100,000 to $200,000 a person. Building traditional units from scratch, meanwhile, can push $500,000 each at current costs and rates.
The proposal will sit idle for several weeks while zoning concerns are ironed out. Mr. Coghill and Ms. Gross, along with other city and county officials, should use that time to consider all the details that will make or break this creative concept. The first of which is: Who is it for?




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.