Traffic calming infrastructure barely slows down drivers, but it massively protects pedestrians and cyclists, especially children. Last Friday’s near-tragedy in the Hill District, when 4-year-old Elijah Rivers was struck and injured by a driver wielding an SUV, is another reminder that making it harder to speed can save lives.
From 1980 to 2010, the rate of pedestrian fatalities consistently dropped. But in the last 15 years, it’s nearly doubled. The obvious culprit would be the advent of smartphones, but America’s rates are outliers among other developed nations. Something is different here. The two most likely culprits are the large size of our cars and roads built for drivers — for speed and efficiency rather than safety for a variety of uses — even in residential areas.
Pittsburgh can’t dampen the market for big cars, but it can make its streets safer for everyone. That’s the purpose of the Neighborhood Traffic Calming Program, part of the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure.
In a reflection of public desire for traffic calming measures, DOMI’s program received record funding of over $1 million in Mayor Ed Gainey’s 2024 budget. It’s a smart investment. Unfortunately, however, the department’s online dashboard hasn’t been updated with 2023’s projects, so it’s hard for the public to know how far last year’s $640,000 appropriation went.
In 2022, DOMI listed 13 projects — a mix of speed bumps, speed cushions (which includes cutouts for bicycles) and speed tables (raised pavement that spans an entire intersection) — on a budget of $750,000. That’s nearly $60,000 per project, a steep cost. Estimates from around the country indicate that a speed table, the most expensive option, should cost $10,000 to $20,000.
We’d like to see a more efficient process that will allow more projects to be built more quickly and cheaply. That means loosening some of the site selection criteria, and maybe even pulling back on studying the effects of every single placement. We know traffic calming works; the point now is to spend more money on building and less on studying.
In 2019 and 2021, DOMI installed humps on the Upper Hill portion of Webster, as well as a Middle Hill section of Bedford Ave the next year. The results: nearly 50% decreases in speeding across the board.
These results have been replicated around the city, with the biggest change along Beacon St in Squirrel Hill: an 84% decrease in speeding and an 11 mile-per-hour drop in prevailing speeds.
The Hill District driver said he didn’t realize he’d hit the young boy. If he didn’t — videos from a nearby child care center showed him slowing and then leaving the child lying on the asphalt — that only makes the case for traffic calming more imperative.
Residents of the Hill District have been clamoring for years for traffic calming on the Middle Hill portion of Webster Ave, where Elijah Rivers was struck. They should have gotten it. It could have been worse. Next time, it might be. Spending the funding more efficiently and building more traffic calming infrastructure will help ensure it won’t be.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.