A marathon, robust and intelligent debate at Pittsburgh City Council last Wednesday shed further light on — and raised further questions about — the Gainey administration’s bid to spend $6 million on a first-of-its-kind comprehensive plan for Pittsburgh. There’s good reason to believe the plan’s technical aspects, even at a roughly $3.5 million price point for top-of-the-line consultants, will be worth it. But the $2.6 million cost for community engagement, with minimal public details about what that engagement will entail, remains exorbitant.
Council passed both parts of the plan through committee on unusual, but encouragingly independent-minded, split votes. Today, members should pass the technical plan so work can get started, while rejecting the engagement bill.
Comprehensive plans are staples of modern city governance, and supportive councilors made a strong case that developing such a plan will be cost effective for Pittsburgh. It is likely that having this plan will unlock more opportunities for grants, and will be more efficient than producing individual neighborhood plans.
But spending nearly $10 per capita simply to listen to citizens’ voices — or to make citizens feel like their voices are being heard — is an unprecedented use of taxpayer dollars. The process by which the money will be divvied up lacks specificity and accountability, leaving Pittsburghers unsure about where their money is going, and what it’s paying for. Mr. Gainey needs to generate a cheaper, more detailed plan that will ensure the public’s confidence in the plan, and protect respected community organizations from undue suspicion.
For instance, the request for proposals (RFP) released by the city is extremely brief, and includes no description of the engagement services requested. It does, however, indicate that the comprehensive plan is to be based on “climate justice” and “just transition” (that is, transition from fossil fuels) principles.
The administration has also been cagey about who is getting the money. The resolution presented to City Council lists only two firms: Downtown-based Common Cause Consultants and international agency Sasaki.
But in a document released to council members — and only posted online at the urging of Councilwoman Deb Gross, a plan skeptic — the Planning Department revealed that several subcontractors had already been decided: $210,000 for 1Hood Media, $100,000 for Brown Mamas (an advocacy group for Black women), $71,000 for local environmental justice advocate Alyssa Lyon, and more.
Further, nearly $700,000 has been set aside for to-be-named community groups, apparently at the discretion of Common Cause. While the document indicates some vague deliverables, such as an “engagement plan,” when pressed about who would be running point for the program, the answer from city planning officials was, once again, Common Cause.
It’s also unclear how much money will be spent by the contractors and subcontractors on personnel, goods and services, and how much will be passed along directly to citizens as part of trendy paid engagement programs. The entire operation may prove to be above board, but this is a lot of taxpayer money to throw around with a vague remit and minimal oversight.
Last Wednesday’s substantive discussion was City Council at its best: skeptical, inquisitive, informed. The body can see through that spirit of prudence and professionalism by passing Mr. Gainey’s bid for a comprehensive plan, while sending him back to the drawing board on his exorbitant community engagement plan.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.