“I am sick and tired of losing to Ohio.” No, those are not the words of Penn State football coach James Franklin. That’s Pennsylvania’s governor, Josh Shapiro. And it’s about time someone said it.

For decades now, Pennsylvania has simply declined to compete at the level of other states with similar sizes and assets — Ohio, North Carolina, Georgia, Michigan — for economic development projects. Instead, the commonwealth has mostly passively accepted the projects that fall into its lap, with the exception of sporadic, ad hoc incentive bids, such as the $1.6 billion subsidy that brought the Shell cracker plant to Beaver County.

The prevailing attitude in Harrisburg, despite hundreds of hard-working people trying to make the best of it, has been that companies should be honored to operate in Pennsylvania, not that Pennsylvania should be honored to host them. That’s charming, but a deeply unrealistic way to operate in the 21st century competitive marketplace.

Because Pennsylvania has lacked a coherent economic development strategy, the state generally collects the dregs leftover once other states have had their fill — or whatever smaller regional consortiums, such as the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, can attract on their own. For instance, when Intel selected the Columbus, Ohio, metro area for its 1,000-acre, $20 billion microchip foundry, Pennsylvania wasn’t even considered a serious candidate.

Advertise with us

It’s in this context that Mr. Shapiro unveiled his 10-year economic development plan for the commonwealth this week, including a Wednesday visit to Mill 19, the RIDC-developed facility in the Hazelwood Green brownfield site. The plan, which includes surprisingly detailed policy proposals, is the fulfillment of every Keystone State economic development professional’s dreams. Whether it works will depend entirely on how aggressively Mr. Shapiro, and the bureaucracy he leads, follows through.

Ambitious goals

Mr. Shapiro’s plan — called “Pennsylvania Gets It Done,” which appears to be a subtle play on his more earthy governing motto, “Get S— Done” — highlights five key sectors which Pennsylvania can prioritize to maximize its reach in the national and global economy: agriculture, energy, life sciences, manufacturing and robotics and technology.

No surprises here, since these are all the trendy economic development sectors — except agriculture, which is an encouraging addition that recognizes its centrality to the state’s economy and culture. Pennsylvania’s farms, per the report, contribute over $130 billion to the state’s economy, and produce more food than all but three other states’ agriculture sectors.

The plan goes on to offer five specific metrics for judging success over the next decade, including rising from 41st state to top 15 for job creation; rising from 35th state to top 10 in median wage growth; and increasing the state’s share of start-ups in high growth industries from 6.6% to 10%. These are ambitious goals, and it’s even more ambitious to announce them publicly. It’ll be up to the people of the commonwealth to hold their government accountable.

Ambitious plans

Besides precise goals, the plan also comes with unusually precise policy proposals for getting there.

Advertise with us

Among the most promising is the creation of a Pennsylvania Certified Shovel Ready Sites program. While other states invested in these ready-to-build business sites — where all permits are already secured, all land already cleared and graded, all utilities already installed — Pennsylvania has lagged behind, increasing the costs in time and money for businesses to set up shop here.

Another important proposal is the streamlining of the state’s currently byzantine economic development bureaucracy, which makes it difficult for businesses even to know what incentives might be available to them. This is one of the reasons — with lack of funding being the main one — the commonwealth lags so far behind regional competitors in the amount of incentives offered. From 2018 to 2022, Pennsylvania handed out $136 million per year in business incentives, while Virginia offered over $300 million per year, and Ohio over $1 billion.

These incentives aren’t without risk: Businesses sometimes fail to provide the promised public benefits, in terms of job growth and other economic activity, or they just fail completely. Sometimes the state ends up with egg on its face. But the alternative is not to play the game at all, while states like Ohio clean up — and see post-pandemic job growth that should embarrass its eastern neighbor.

Lastly, the plan’s workforce training proposals — specifically the expansion of apprenticeships in the skilled trades and the removal of barriers to reentering the economy for the previously incarcerated — provide a needed focus on keeping talented Pennsylvanians in Pennsylvania jobs.

Ambitious spirit

Mr. Shapiro’s plan couldn’t arrive a minute too soon for the Pittsburgh region, which has struggled more than almost any other in the country to recover from the COVID pandemic. A recent presentation by Don Smith, president of the Regional Industrial Development Corporation of Southwestern Pennsylvania (RIDC), pointed to discouraging job losses over the last five years, particularly in so-called “traded clusters” — that is, industries that export goods and services beyond the local region. In the ten-country region, only Beaver saw an uptick, while Indiana and Greene lost a full quarter of such jobs since 2018.

Advertise with us

At the same time, federal investments in clean energy manufacturing have skipped Pittsburgh, and Pennsylvania as a whole, entirely — despite the region’s tremendous educational and geographical assets. The winners: the Southeast and the Midwest, including — you guessed it — Ohio.

Indeed, as we have previously written, under current leadership the Pittsburgh region has suddenly seemed more inward-looking, and less ambitious. Mr. Shapiro and his economic development plan, however, bring precisely the opposite spirit: one of optimism and energy, one that focuses on what this city and this state have to offer the world, rather than on what’s wrong with them.

In the coming months and years, we’ll keep tabs on the progress toward Mr. Shapiro’s goals. Right now, though, we can only repeat: It’s about time.