By its next meeting on Feb. 1, two-thirds of the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board’s members will be newcomers. It marks a new era of operations for the decades-old board, and there are plenty of reasons to be optimistic: The first meeting of the year, featuring County Executive Sara Innamorato just two days after her swearing-in, was civil and organized compared to the performative gatherings of the past.
Arguably the most important change is Ms. Innamorato herself. Her presence shows a commitment and personal investment in the Board, which will be especially important as the search for Warden Orlando Harper’s successor continues. Former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald rarely joined the meeting during his tenure, when meetings often devolved into shouting matches.
The new county executive joins two Court of Common Pleas judges, two attorneys with indigent defense experience and a community activist previously incarcerated in the jail on the Oversight Board. Only three board members are staying through the transition: councilor Bethany Hallam, Sheriff Kevin Kraus and County Controller Corey O’Connor. At this first meeting, the board unanimously voted to create official bylaws — a basic housekeeping measure the last iteration of the Board was too dysfunctional to achieve.
The two new judges, Susan Evashavik DiLucente and Kelly Eileen Bigley, will act as the intermediaries between the board and the county judiciary, while attorneys Barbara Griffin and Rob Perkins will bring criminal justice experience from the other side of the bench. The appointment of Muhammad Ali Nasir, known as MAN-E, fulfills Ms. Innamorato’s promise to include a previously incarcerated person on the Board.
The only obvious gap in expertise is in healthcare: No medical professionals currently sit on the board. The quality of care in the jail has been an ongoing concern, especially after the revelation the jail had hired a physician, Dr. Wilson Bernales, whose license to practice had been repeatedly suspended. Medical professionals at the jail must handle everything from bumps and bruises to mental health crises and medications for opioid use disorder — and sometimes withdrawal. In the future, bringing a physician onto the Board will allow it to properly supervise this aspect of jail operations, and possibly recruit compassionate personnel.
Indeed, the biggest structural challenge facing the Board is the jail’s untenable staffing situation. There are 90 medical staff vacancies going into the new year, with contract workers filling the gaps. Meanwhile, an acute lack of corrections officers puts everyone at risk — of violence, of burnout, of abuse.
Most of all, the Board must ensure that incarceration is not a death sentence, and that Allegheny County Jail’s unacceptable number of fatalities in custody over the last decade is addressed fully and honestly.
The era of the Jail Oversight Board as performance art, where showing off for a cadre of activists (among both board members and public commenters) replaced sober deliberation, has seemingly come to an end. And the Board mustn’t backslide, if the goal really is to make the Allegheny County Jail safer, more secure and more just.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.