While the children of Pittsburgh rejoiced on Tuesday morning, parents and caregivers groaned: Pittsburgh Public Schools announced a full closure after 8 a.m., throwing thousands of families’ schedules into chaos.

But the joke was on the kids, because there was barely enough powder to make a decent snow angel. Which raises the question: Why was the region’s biggest district closed for only three (at most) inches of snow?

The simple answer is that the city didn’t clear even main roads quickly enough for a two-hour delay to suffice for safe travel.

This represents a decline from Mayor Ed Gainey’s first year in office. The Editorial Board praised the city’s efficiency during a December 2022 storm, and in the early days of his term Mr. Gainey used social media and video messages to communicate with Pittsburghers about snow events. His very first photo op was a snow-plow ride-along in Brookline.

Advertise with us

Even when things didn’t go as they should have, Mr. Gainey was visibly interested in brass tacks concerns.

But on Tuesday, the administration released no public information about snow clearance: no press releases, no social media posts, no explanations for causing 18,000 children to lose a day of school. Further, the online snow plow tracker spearheaded by former mayor Bill Peduto, and praised by Mr. Gainey in his first month in office, no longer functions properly, leaving the public even more confused and anxious about the roads.

Families need to be confident schools will close only under truly unusual weather conditions, and children need to see public institutions that model resilience, not fragility.

Snow clearance, even of just a few inches, is a more complicated matter than it might seem. Officials have to maintain regular communication with department heads while navigating complex union regulations and dealing with rapidly changing conditions. Having a good system in place, while adapting to circumstances, is a good test of a city’s leadership.

Tuesday’s snow was more like a brief quiz, and the Gainey administration still struggled.

Advertise with us

It’s true that even a small amount of snow at just the wrong time, such as morning or afternoon rush hour, especially if it comes by surprise, can snarl traffic and make efficiently cleaning Pittsburgh’s complex 900-mile road network a herculean task. Early Tuesday morning’s snowfall, however, was in line with the National Weather Service’s modest predictions and began long before dawn.

Yet even after 9 a.m. — several hours into the event — primary roads in the East End, North Side and elsewhere remained untouched by DPW vehicles, leaving cars sliding rather than rolling to work or (hastily arranged) child care.

Which means PPS was right to cancel school, but the district’s hand shouldn’t have been forced. This isn’t Atlanta, where a dusting of powder induces mass panic. This is a city where a few inches of pre-dawn snow is commonplace, and should be handled with ease.

But on Tuesday, fulfilling the city’s basic duties felt like an afterthought.