It’s about time: The City of Pittsburgh has announced it will begin enforcing its Paid Sick Days Act this month, a policy that will affect all businesses with workers inside city limits. This move is particularly significant for public-facing jobs like restaurant staff and childcare providers, where the absence of paid sick leave has been a longstanding issue.

Paid time off for illness and medical appointments should be a basic part of employment, not a luxury, and the city’s ordinance reflects that truth. Enforcement, however, has proven challenging, and will continue to be challenging as long as the law remains in effect.

Questions about whether the law applies retroactively; when and how fines should be meted out; the policy’s impacts on tip-dependent industries; and what exactly constitutes working “within the city” after the popularization of work-from-home plans all still need to be addressed. These complications highlight how difficult these kinds of regulations are to enforce — and why they usually come from state and federal governments, not municipal governments.

In Pittsburgh, enforcement will come from the three-person Office of Equal Protection, which Mayor Ed Gainey created last summer to handle worker protection laws. The tiny OEP, which Mr. Gainey brought into the Mayor’s Office, is now tasked with ensuring compliance with measures like the Americans with Disabilities Act, local disruptive properties laws and paid sick leave.

Advertise with us

The city’s first enforcement efforts will primarily focus on the food service industry in the 15201 and 15203 zip codes, which cover substantial portions of Lawrenceville and the South Side.

Under the act, workers may accrue an hour of sick time for every 35 hours worked within city limits, for up to 40 hours. For businesses with fewer than 15 employees, workers can bank up to 24 hours. Businesses must have an established sick leave policy that falls in line with these guidelines and display them in a place accessible to all employees to achieve compliance.

The sick leave law has been mired in legal uncertainties since its passage in 2015, up to its full implementation in 2021. This long process has created understandable confusion, for city employees as well as business owners, who must now calculate accrued sick time and possible fines going back three or four years.

During the pandemic, the federal CARES Act gave Americans a small taste of national sick leave. Since then, it’s been up to states and localities to fill the gaps. Allegheny County’s own paid sick leave policy went into effect in 2021. Nearby, Maryland, New York and New Jersey already have their own policies, and Governor Josh Shapiro has voiced support for similar action in Pennsylvania, which we would support — if only because Harrisburg has much greater regulatory capacity than Grant Street.

Still, Mr. Gainey’s attempt to enforce a law he inherited by building out an Office of Equal Protection is praiseworthy. The time and expense should give the Mayor and City Council pause, however, before further regulating economic justice.