Over the last 12 years, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board — in its various forms — has had several bones to pick with former Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald.
The Board castigated Mr. Fitzgerald and former Pittsburgh mayor Bill Peduto for their secrecy regarding the region’s bid for Amazon’s second headquarters. The Board criticized a leadership style that was often seen as imperious and autocratic. And, in recent months, the Board has observed Mr. Fitzgerald’s apparent inattentiveness to the county’s responsibilities to the most vulnerable: people incarcerated in the county jail and living on the streets.
None of these are small matters, but neither do they present a complete view of 12 years of leadership of one of the biggest local governments between New York and Chicago.
In truth, taken as a whole, Mr. Fitzgerald’s tenure was marked by far more triumphs than failures. And in fulfilling his most basic responsibility — stewarding public resources and institutions so they can be passed on, not just intact but more robust than he found them — his three terms must be regarded as successful.
A cap full of feathers
Mr. Fitzgerald leaves his post with a record that would have been unthinkable when he ascended to it: twelve years without a tax increase, while the county’s financial reserves have grown and services have generally remained consistent or expanded. The fact this stability has come to be seen by Allegheny County residents as normal, when for most places in the Rust Belt it is merely aspirational, is a testament to Mr. Fitzgerald’s quiet competence as an administrator.
Western Pennsylvanians can also thank Mr. Fitzgerald, and the leaders he empowered, for two transformative infrastructure projects: the $300 million Bus Rapid Transit link from Downtown to the East End via Oakland, and the $1.5 billion modernization of Pittsburgh International Airport, which is funded almost entirely by airlines, not taxpayers. The airport has also emerged from the doldrums that followed the loss of its hub status, adding dozens of new routes, while hosting the Neighborhood 91 manufacturing center.
Mr. Fitzgerald can also claim modest success in his primary goal: to restore economic vibrancy to Allegheny County, measured first and foremost by population and jobs. The 2010s were the first decade since the 1950s during which the county gained residents, and the unemployment rate is at a record low.
Population and job gains, however, were reversed during the COVID pandemic, and the region has struggled to regain its footing in the aftermath.
Pandemic leadership
While COVID dampened Mr. Fitzgerald’s economic record, it also showcased his leadership. The former county executive earned near-universal plaudits for his decisive management during the crisis.
His weekly press conferences with Health Department director Dr. Debra Bogen projected calm, confidence and expertise. The consortium of university leaders he convened resulted in coordinated efforts to serve tens of thousands of students and employees, as well as to effectively distribute the COVID vaccine. Smart collaboration with private charities ensured essential services were delivered while schools and other institutions shut down.
Not everyone agreed with every decision Mr. Fitzgerald made, but he made those decisions with authority — and that’s what counted most during the emergency.
Unfinished business
One area, however, where Mr. Fitzgerald declined to make the hard-but-necessary decision was in ordering a countywide real estate reassessment. This time bomb he handed down to his successor, Sara Innamorato, and she must deal with it during her four-year term. It is one of the few bequests from the Fitzgerald years she will deplore, and that may come to define her tenure.
The county’s financial stability is also due in part to an artificially high common level ratio — a complex calculation that determines the taxable value of property — which will present challenges for Ms. Innamorato’s future budgets.
Mr. Fitzgerald leaves Ms. Innamorato some vacancies, which he declined to fill out of deference to his successor — most notably the county jail warden and the Health Department director. As of this writing, however, Ms. Innamorato has dismissed none of Mr. Fitzgerald’s major appointments, again testifying to the stability of the government she inherits.
Fitz in context
Rich Fitzgerald served as Allegheny County Executive for half of that office’s existence, and his personality — obsessively hard-working, constantly communicative, unapologetically decisive — has come to define it in ways that will both benefit and challenge his successor.
He took office as a representative of the Democratic left, but his preference for pragmatism over purity earned him respect on his right flank and contempt on his left. That he leaves office as the bogeyman of progressive Pittsburgh shows just how much the region’s center of political gravity has shifted in the last 12 years.
He wasn’t perfect. As with any leader, he had blind spots, and the qualities that made him effective sometimes betrayed him. He made enemies and attracted criticism — including, from time to time, from this Board.
And yet very few people in Western Pennsylvania will cheer his departure, or look back on his tenure with regret. The truth is, despite the negativity endemic in this region, Allegheny County has been fortunate to have three consecutive capable executives for its first 24 years under a home rule charter.
Rich Fitzgerald, perhaps most of all, will be a hard act to follow.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.