Pittsburgh needs to overhaul its zoning system and land use principles. But a bid by the Gainey administration to spend nearly $6 million — including about $2.5 million for community engagement alone — on a comprehensive plan is a wasteful extravagance that should be rejected by City Council.
In a sign the administration’s spell over council may finally be weakening, several members expressed sticker shock while asking sharp questions of Planning Department chief Karen Abrams during a marathon standing committee meeting on Wednesday. The most alarming revelation: More than half the $2.5 million community engagement budget is earmarked for unaccountable payments to city residents for their “participation” in the project.
The skeptical legislature put off the resolutions until Monday, when public conversations with the executive branch will continue, followed by a vote on whether to refer the measures for final passage.
Councilors should not allow themselves to be cowed by the Mayor’s Office over the weekend. And on Monday they should finally stand up to Ed Gainey and his deputies by voting down the exorbitant contracts.
Sticker shock
The City of Pittsburgh is not currently operating under a comprehensive plan. Rather, in a reflection of its complex geography, the city has a variety of plans, from stormwater plans to shade tree plans to dozens of neighborhood plans, that overlap and intersect in impossibly complex ways.
The lack of coordination leads to knotty problems, such as stifling residential development. As we have previously described, well-intentioned zoning rules that simultaneously require affordability and limit height end up ruling out all viable projects in high-need neighborhoods. There is no question the city’s zoning code, in particular, is antiquated.
In this regard, Councilwoman Erika Strassburger, the most vocal supporter of the comprehensive plan at Wednesday’s meeting, is absolutely correct: Pittsburgh’s patchwork of visions are a great way to ensure none of them are realized. Comprehensive plans are a fixture of modern city governance, and can also unlock federal and other grants.
But it’s precisely in comparison to other cities where Mr. Gainey’s bid begins to look unusual. Councilwoman Deb Gross observed at the meeting that Chicago — a city nine times Pittsburgh’s size — recently completed a somewhat less ambitious comprehensive plan that cost that city only about $4 million in outside consultants. A Peduto administration attempt to build out a more piecemeal plan, nixed by the Gainey administration, was largely done in-house.
In that context, it’s clear councilors were right to balk at the price tag — especially when so much of the money is earmarked for an unaccountable “community engagement” plan.
Money everywhere
The two proposed appropriations are $3.26 million for the technical aspects of the plan, to be completed by the firms HR&A Advisors and Urban American City, and $2.65 million for community engagement by the firms Common Cause Consultants and Sasaki. Common Cause is a local company, while the remainder are major national and international consultants.
While the cost for the plan itself isn’t cheap, it’s not radically out of keeping with an ambitious comprehensive plan for a mid-sized city. The community engagement, however, attracted the attention of Councilman Anthony Coghill, who asked the natural question: What could this possibly be paying for?
The answer from Common Cause Consultants principal LaTrenda Leonard Sherrill surprised council, and should have raised alarm bells: More than half of the $2.65 million will be distributed among individuals, much of the remainder among community organization. In other words, council would be authorizing millions of taxpayer dollars to be distributed willy-nilly by a third party.
Compensating residents for their feedback is a trendy practice in community engagement. It is said to ensure equitable representation in community feedback by ensuring people can afford to spend their time at neighborhood meetings or other engagement opportunities — certainly a noble goal.
But over $2 million is an outrageous sum for such a plan. The city of Rochester, Minn., one-third Pittsburgh’s size, recently paid 10 people $25 an hour for 30 hours to be part of a community advisory board. The money the Gainey administration proposes would pay for up to 300 similar boards. Indeed, at the standard $25 rate, the contract could pay for up to 100,000 hours of paid feedback — an absurd figure.
In public life, even the appearance of impropriety must be scrupulously avoided, and this certainly looks like it could be abused as unaccountable walking-around money for friends and allies. If City Council ultimately approves a community engagement contract for a comprehensive plan, it must require detailed reports of how consultants spend taxpayer dollars.
Do it right
There’s no question Pittsburgh needs a comprehensive plan, led by rethinking zoning and land use in favor of residential development and building sustainable, broadly shared prosperity across 90 neighborhoods. But Pittsburgh does not need the $6 million contracts the Gainey administration is proposing.
Council should stick to its guns and send the Mayor back to the drawing board to develop a more cost-effective and accountable bid, especially for community engagement. If and when a comprehensive plan does come to pass, council should provide oversight to ensure a true diversity of perspectives are included: The plan mustn’t be a vanity project to bake a single mayor’s priorities into the next 25 years of city governance.
A comprehensive plan is a great opportunity for Pittsburgh to have an integrated framework for its development and its leaders’ decision-making. But if done poorly, it can be at best wasteful, and at worst an albatross that encumbers the city for decades. So there’s no rush: The important thing is to do it right.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.