In March 2020, as the COVID pandemic ravaged the overcrowded U.S. prison system, the Trump administration passed the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act. One of its many provisions expanded home confinement to allow roughly 13,000 nonviolent offenders to serve their federal sentences at home. The program has helped around 10,000 former inmates re-enter society with (so far) a very low recidivism rate — in addition to protecting them from COVID and other hazards of living together so closely with so many other people in prison.

But this October, Senator Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., introduced S.J. Res. 47, which would end this program, and reincarcerate the 3,000 prisoners still serving their sentences this way. Cosponsors include Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., Ted Cruz, R-Texas and J. D. Vance, R-Ohio.

While many COVID-era emergency measures should come to an end now that the emergency is over, others, like the home-release rule, demonstrated their long-term value: The outcomes of home confinement have shown massive improvements over those of regular incarceration.

Backtracking after nearly three years of success would be an emotional response to fear of nonviolent offenders, not a rational response to reality. And, in the long-run, it will likely make our streets less safe.

Advertise with us

Of the 10,000 participants who’ve been released, only 22 have been rearrested, mostly on drug offenses. That’s a recidivism rate of 0.17%. The rate is so low partly because those selected for the program had already met multiple criteria for success and reliability, and partly because the program itself, not least the participants being home, fosters a smoother reentry process.

Supervised inmates under home confinement have increased opportunities to rebuild their lives, create connections for future employment and education, and maintain and develop their relations with their families and neighbors. Additionally, the cost-effective program costs $55 per day compared to $121 in prison.

Ms. Blackburn, maybe forgetting that the CARES Act passed under former President Trump, claimed the Biden administration’s “soft-on-crime policies” have “enabled violent criminals to flourish.” But if anything, supervised home release makes communities safer by removing nonviolent offenders from the dehumanizing environment in U.S. prisons. The politicians advocating for this bill seem more focused on projecting an image of being "tough on crime" than actually reducing crime.

President Joe Biden has pledged to veto S.J. Res. 47 should it arrive at his desk, but it shouldn’t get that far. In fact, while the 3,000 individuals in the COVID-era program continue safely and humanely serving their terms at home, lawmakers should be taking up the opposite question: Given the demonstrated advantages of noncustodial sentences for both inmates and taxpayers, how can the Bureau of Prisons expand on the program’s success?