The evidence that solitary confinement does significant, long-term and irreversible damage only grows.

Five inmates filed a lawsuit Tuesday alleging that conditions in a Pennsylvania state prison are “tortuous,” worsening or creating mental illness in those held there. All of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit have spent at least a year in solitary. For one one man, according to the suit, it was roughly 12.

The lawsuit specifically focused on conditions in the State Correctional Institution at Fayette, 45 miles south of Pittsburgh. It currently holds 30-50 men in solitary confinement, also known by the euphemism “administrative segregation,” in its Security Threat Group Management unit.

It’s beyond time for this practice to end. In 1994’s Farmer v. Brennan, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that solitary doesn’t violate the Eighth Amendment prohibition on “cruel and unusual punishment” unless there is proven “substantial risk of serious harm” and “deliberate indifference” on the part of prison authorities. Modern research, plus the facts laid out in the suit, clear both hurdles.

Advertise with us

The lawsuit alleges that authorities placed inmates into confinement based on secret evidence, making it impossible for them to challenge their punishment, and offered inadequate mental health support or addiction treatment services.

It’s shameful that public institutions, which act on the public’s behalf, still treat human beings with this level of callousness — especially in the face of decades of clear evidence that solitary confinement leads to severe mental decline and anguish.

The stories in the lawsuit are harrowing: 22 hours a day locked in a cell no larger than 80 square feet with permanent bright lights and no windows to the outdoors. One hour of outdoor time may be spent in another cage, but the lawsuit claims that mental decline led inmates to refuse the option. One plaintiff said he attempted suicide more than ten times during his confinement. Others experienced paranoia, sleeping disorders and audio and visual hallucinations.

Pennsylvania’s justice system already knows the consequences of this type of treatment. In 2015, the state Department of Corrections entered a settlement agreement with the Disability Rights Network barring the use of 23-hour-a-day confinement for seriously mentally ill inmates.

What this doesn’t acknowledge is that isolation can create seriously mentally ill inmates.

Advertise with us

A 2023 study for Social Work Research surveyed over 200 previously incarcerated adults and provided clear results: “Solitary confinement was significantly associated with higher levels of current psychosis symptoms.” Prison isolation has also been linked to more instances of self harm, difficulties in cognition, depression and PTSD.

Prison is, at least in part, about preparing incarcerated people to successfully re-enter society, and solitary confinement undermines that purpose.

Courts have also been extremely explicit in deriding the use of solitary confinement. In 2017, a Third Circuit court ruled that “in the absence of interaction with others, an individual’s very identity is at risk of disintegration.”

In other words, we know what predictably happens when people are subjected to these conditions. Now we have to recognize it in law, and choose to stop.