On Wednesday, a county executive held a press conference alongside several regional service providers announcing the expansion of a county program to ensure all unhoused people have shelter during the coldest days and nights of winter.
That was Adam Bello, county executive of Monroe County, N.Y., home of the city of Rochester. The announcement throws into sharp relief the failures of Allegheny County to prepare for a predictably difficult winter for homeless services. New information shows that during the pre-Thanksgiving chill and post-Thanksgiving cold snap, nearly every shelter bed in the county — including the overflow beds promised by county officials — has been full, and outreach workers have been reduced to distributing “survival supplies” to help people on the streets live through the night.
The crisis comes, unfortunately, during a leadership transition from County Executive Rich Fitzgerald to County Executive-elect Sara Innamorato, which means the focus of county officials is on ensuring the orderly handover of authority. But this, too, was predictable, and yet the county’s Department of Human Services (DHS) has been caught flat-footed.
As Ms. Innamorato considers which of her predecessor’s appointees she should retain, she should begin with a serious look at the leadership at DHS, looking most closely at how badly they prepared to serve the homeless this winter.
An unprecedented rebuke
While Rochester officials were announcing the expansion of their Code Blue cold safety initiative, the Allegheny County Homeless Advisory Board was delivering an unprecedented rebuke to city and county human services officials. At its regular monthly meeting on Tuesday, the typically quiet and ineffectual panel voted to send a letter demanding that Pittsburgh and Allegheny County fulfill their joint pledge to make emergency shelter space available for the coming cold snap.
Read More
But nothing happened.
The plea may not have had legal force, but it had moral force. Due to the permanent closure of the shelter at the Smithfield United Church of Christ in Downtown, and despite opening overflow space at Second Avenue Commons, the county has a deficit of well over 100 overnight shelter beds. Meanwhile, entering November, the county reported the second-highest number of people experiencing unsheltered homelessness — that is, living and sleeping completely outdoors — since the online dashboard began in late 2021.
As a result, multiple service providers confirmed to the Post-Gazette Editorial Board that they had to turn people away, including on Tuesday night, when the low was 18 degrees and the wind chill dropped to single digits. The providers distributed items such as socks, jackets and tents — as well as hopes and prayers that the recipients would live to see the sunrise.
In these conditions, the human body begins to change. Blood becomes thicker, and people become more prone to heart attacks and strokes. The body becomes worse at fighting infection. For weeks after exposure to extreme cold, people are more vulnerable to illness, turning coughs and flu into killers like pneumonia.
Code Blue
That’s why cities and counties across the U.S. have created so-called “Code Blue” programs, where services are ramped up when temperatures drop below a certain threshold. In past winters, Allegheny County has opened emergency shelters when nights go below 25 degrees, but those shelters are either permanently closed (Smithfield) or already open (Second Avenue overflow) without any vacancies.
Despite a city-county promise that “an emergency facility will be activated” when temperatures plunge and overflows fill up, Tuesday night’s frigid temperatures triggered no new contingencies.
In Rochester, Monroe County announced a modest expansion of its Code Blue system, with 41 overflow shelter beds and the distribution of cards that map bus routes to warming centers and entitle the carriers to free trips. Philadelphia has a Code Blue hotline that bystanders can call to summon outreach workers to an unsheltered person on cold days and nights. Other cities park running buses near encampments so people have a place to temporarily warm up.
What unites Code Blue programs is a commitment to ensure it is at least possible for every homeless person to have a warm place to be. Right now, Allegheny County is not meeting this baseline of humaneness.
This winter, and next
It is too late for the county to build out the cold weather capacity it needs for this winter: Even the simple Code Blue operation in Monroe County, N.Y., took several months of planning and coordination to come together. But it is not too late to generate emergency plans to keep people alive this winter — and to begin to plan for next.
In the past, public and private outreach workers have turned daytime spaces, such as the Reaching Out On The Streets (ROOTS) health care sites, into ad hoc overnight warming centers. This is far from ideal, but it keeps people warm, and alive. Even if more permanent solutions can’t be brought on line this season, the county has the resources — a $40 million homeless services budget within a $1 billion DHS budget — for creative stop-gaps, such as modest 24/7 warming centers and Pittsburgh Regional Transit buses.
But this is also the time to begin to build a sustainable, long-term plan for wintertime homelessness — Allegheny County’s own Code Blue. But without a serious change in approach and priorities, DHS’s current leadership appears unable to see this through with the necessary care, creativity and foresight.
As Sara Innamorato prepares to take the reins in January, she should scrutinize DHS closely, and insist that leaders — including director Erin Dalton and deputy director for community services Abigail Horn — either demonstrate their willingness to think bigger, or step aside.
Getting Allegheny County’s unsheltered people through the winter alive will be the new executive’s first test of leadership.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.