A new report from the website Black Pittsburgh demonstrates the ongoing structural injustices based by Black people in the criminal justice system. While the causes of these disparities are frustratingly and seemingly infinitely complex, they cannot be ignored. Local leaders at all nodes of the criminal justice system, from law enforcement to prosecutors to executive branch leaders, should launch a task force to understand why racial disparities are so large, and what can be done, working together, to mitigate them.
The Black Pittsburgh investigation looked at the number of cases in Allegheny County thus far in 2023 in which Black people were defendants, 48.6%, and compared it to the percent of the population that is Black, 13.5%. Then it took the same numbers for white residents: 49.1% and 79.1%, respectively. Comparing the ratios yields a startling figure: Black county residents are 5.8 times more likely to be charged with a crime than white ones.
The report also contains figures that demonstrate that the disparity in charges is downstream from the disparity in arrests. Thus far in 2023, about two in three arrests made by the Pittsburgh Police were of Black people, and less than one in three were of white people. Performing the same analysis — comparing these figures to populations — yields an even higher result: In the city Black people are more than six times more likely to be arrested than white people.
Perhaps most alarmingly, the report indicates that the charging discrepancy is on the rise, from 4.4 times in 2013 to 5.8 times today. There is no indication of whether policies — either of policing or prosecuting — or underlying social conditions contributed to this rise.
These figures, besides being disturbing in themselves, compare unfavorably to other cities, including nearby Cleveland and Newark, whose mayor Ras Baraka visited Pittsburgh to speak on violence prevention with Mayor Ed Gainey last week. One data point that shows both how high Pittsburgh’s disparity is, and how difficult it is to address, comes from Philadelphia. The office of progressive district attorney Larry Krasner reports that, between 2015 and 2022, during which Mr. Krasner served as DA for five of the eight years, Black residents were charged with crimes 2.6 times more often than white residents.
These disparities both reflect and perpetuate the de facto segregation and economic dispossession of Black communities, in Pittsburgh and elsewhere. While simply declining to arrest and charge people who break the law, especially violently, is not a legitimate option, these disparities are not sustainable. From community-based violence prevention — which Pittsburgh’s cash-flush Stop the Violence Fund is supposed to be supporting — all the way to prosecutors and judges, everyone has a role to play in reducing racial disparities in the criminal justice system.
That means the county needs an all-hand-on-deck approach. No matter who wins tomorrow’s elections, Allegheny County’s new leaders should commit, together, to forming a team to study and reduce these disparities.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.