An otherwise sensible bid by the state legislature to reinstate the Spin scooters pilot program in Pittsburgh nonetheless gives marching orders to local government, harmfully impinging on the city’s power to govern itself.
On matters that affect Pittsburgh residents, Pittsburgh’s city government is the closest and most competent authority. The state should only get involved to the minimum extent necessary. That means authorizing a scooter pilot program, but leaving to the city when and how to implement it.
Pittsburgh launched the Spin pilot program in mid-2021 amid great excitement over an innovative way to get around. The public-private partnership — San Francisco-based Spin provided the scooters for free in exchange for usage data to help optimize the system — was meant to offer a low-emissions option for short trips.
The scooters quickly fell out of favor with city residents, however, because the heavy devices were often left in inconvenient places — blocking sidewalks, taking up residential parking spaces, encroaching on intersections. And while Spin forced users of its app to take a “rules of the road” quiz, pedestrians found themselves frantically dodging them while drivers didn’t know what to do with them.
While the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure and Pittsburgh Regional Transit continued to support the scooters as a “first/last mile” solution for getting people to and from transit hubs, few mourned when state authorization for the pilot expired in July.
Harrisburg is involved at all because the state’s motor vehicle code was written before the advent of so-called “e-scooters,” so that code must be updated to permit them. Now, the state House has placed new language in the Fiscal Code — the enabling legislation needed to activate a significant chunk of the long-delayed state budget — that would bring scooters back. The code now awaits action in the Senate.
The law would give a “city of the second class” — that’s Harrisburg code for Pittsburgh, and Pittsburgh alone — the authority to allow e-scooters as long as its council passes an ordinance and its mayor issues an executive order by Dec. 31, 2023. This timeline gives city officials virtually no time to undertake a serious study of the issue.
The proposal then goes on to authorize City Council to pass an ordinance regulating the use of e-scooters, followed by a detailed list of what that ordinance must contain. The list largely covers topics that became concerns during the initial pilot, such as mechanisms for recording abandoned scooters and collecting fines, but this should be up to the legislators on Grant Street, not Third Street in Harrisburg. Further, it’s not clear what happens if the state’s Dec. 31 deadline runs out.
No matter what you think about the scooters themselves, this is no way to legislate. State lawmakers should give Pittsburgh officials the authorization, and the choice, to bring Spin back in its own time and in its own way. Sending time-sensitive ultimatums disrespects Pittsburgh’s independence and the city's ability to make better decisions for its life than the state legislature.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.