With unstable leadership in City Hall and uncertain leadership in the county executive’s office, now is not the time for Allegheny County to take a chance on an unproven and unpredictable district attorney. To keep a steady hand at the helm in rough waters, voters should retain Stephen Zappala as top prosecutor.
Mr. Zappala has served Allegheny County well for 24 years, and while we have often disagreed with him — and will again in the future — he provides the assurance of stability while Mayor Ed Gainey quietly embraces police defunding and county executive Rich Fitzgerald leaves his post after 12 years.
On the other hand, Mr. Zappala’s opponent, former chief public defender Matt Dugan, is beholden to campaign donors — the Pennsylvania Justice and Public Safety PAC funded entirely by billionaire George Soros has provided nearly $2 million, or over 90% of Mr. Dugan’s financial support — who seek radical transformation in every jurisdiction they invest in. Mr. Dugan’s promises of more measured reform may be sincere, but no one can know — not even himself — how he will react when his funders demand he go farther.
This, at a time when the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police is hemorrhaging officers and Mayor Ed Gainey is decreasing both the budgeted funds and personnel for the department. And while the Mayor and Chief Larry Scirotto have publicly disavowed a consultant’s recommendation that patrol officers be trimmed by one-third, the bureau is quietly reducing the number of officers assigned to some of the city’s six zones.
Into the void, reports the New York Times, especially in cities with progressive leadership such as Portland, Ore., is stepping one of America’s biggest growth industries: private security. In downtowns across America, private officers outnumber sworn officers at least three to one. In other words, in places where law enforcement recedes, security is still available — for those who can afford it.
In times of stability and security, it may be prudent to experiment with more radical changes to law enforcement and criminal justice. Now is not one of those times.
At the same time, Mr. Zappala has quietly proven himself to be a successful, and balanced, reformer. The Allegheny County diversionary courts — Drug Court, Mental Health Court and Veterans Court — which offer treatment and social services as an off-ramp out of the criminal justice system, have become models for other jurisdictions. And, despite perceptions ginned up by activists, the number of people incarcerated at the county jail has declined sharply on his watch — and on his initiative.
We’d like to see more of the same, and we expect we will. The electoral pressure applied by progressive challengers has demonstrated voters’ desire for policy that balances criminal justice reform and public safety.
But it is Stephen Zappala who is most likely to deliver that balance. The Post-Gazette endorses him for Allegheny County District Attorney.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.