The images of violence committed against Israelis by the militant group Hamas, in an ongoing assault that began with a sneak attack on Saturday, must shock the conscience, and remind us of the horrific toll of hatred. There can be no excuse or justification for such attacks, and none for the tactics, especially the kidnappings of women and children to use as human shields. In a further outrage, Hamas has announced its intention to livestream executions of hostages in retaliation for Israeli counteroffensive operations.
As of this writing, 800 are reported dead in Israel, including nine Americans, with 150 Israelis held hostage. Nearly 700 Palestinians, perhaps more, have died.
Hamas, it must be said, does not speak and act for the majority of Palestinians, who oppose the group’s crimes and dread the consequences of its actions, which are and will be suffered by the people of Gaza. Those consequences will include the deaths of Palestinian civilians, in large part because Hamas uses those innocents as shields by placing its military infrastructure among civilian populations. Israel has a right to defend itself.
At the same time, a full siege without humanitarian relief, as has been threatened by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, would fail to recognize the distinction between civilians and militants, and would violate international law.
The personal impact of this war extends to Pittsburgh in a particular way. First, the grief experienced by Jews around world is felt especially keenly here, in the aftermath of the trial that meted out justice in the worst act of antisemitic terror in U.S. history.
Second, in this city with a large and historic Jewish population, many people have personal connections to Israel. Surrounded on all sides by current or past adversaries, Israeli society is always prepared for mass mobilization: Most young adults receive at least two years of military training and are officially enlisted in the reserves.
For hundreds if not thousands of Pittsburghers, friends and family members are currently reporting to their posts for what will likely be a long and bloody conflict. The specter of more Jewish death, close to home, approaches quickly.
At the same time, Pittsburgh is home to growing Muslim and Arab Christian communities, including Palestinians. They also watch helplessly as their people suffer violence and death.
In Pittsburgh and across the United States, members of all these communities are on high alert for hate crimes inspired by the crisis. Let us pledge to care for one another, especially by being careful in our own speech — especially online — in addressing the Hamas attacks and the Israeli response.
We can and must condemn crimes without dehumanizing groups or nations. We must also be cautious of misinformation, including doctored or misrepresented images and videos, meant to stir up anger and hatred.
While the people of Pittsburgh cannot solve the crisis in the Holy Land, we can model the compassion and forbearance necessary for people of different beliefs and backgrounds to live together in peace. That is the only way to reduce violence and hatred, here and everywhere.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.