Meetings of the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board have become gatherings of local activists enjoying their monthly live entertainment — including predictable harangues of board members and jail representatives, and jeers when unruly guests get shown the door. The public beatdown of jail officials, while borne out of sincere grassroots activism, means the board is now struggling to fulfill its actual purpose: monitoring and improving the jail.
This played out as usual last Thursday, when the jail’s new acting warden, Shane Dady, made his first appearance before the Board. This marks the beginning of a lengthy period of change for the jail and for its board: The top job at ACJ will likely take a year to fill, and a new County Executive will take office before the process ends.
This was also an opportune moment for the board to reassess its relationship with jail officials. Unfortunately, the test run went exceptionally poorly.
Board members were too busy arguing among themselves to spend much time talking with Mr. Dady. As a whole, the meeting was combative and myopic, delivering muddy results even when real issues, like a severe staffing shortage, were on the table.
While ACJ's previous procedural failings have been scrutinized for years, the board appears to be fixated on cataloging these errors rather than working collaboratively to address them.
Diving into the nitty-gritty of jail procedures and their shortcomings is a crucial duty for an oversight board, but it should constitute just the initial phase of their work. The board also bears the responsibility for overseeing the jail's ongoing operations, and that involves working with the warden and others to try to fix the problems they find.
One exchange from this month’s meeting, when board member and at-large county councilwoman Bethany Hallam requested more details about a recent lockdown due to safety concerns, revealed the board’s dysfunction.
Ms. Hallam began by noting that staffing shortages were not an authorized reason for locking down sections of the jail. Chief Deputy Warden Jason Beasom responded, explaining that overtime refusals, call-offs and additional medical transports had led to understaffing at a level that compromised safety. Without adequate supervision over inmates, entire pods were closed.
Nonetheless, Ms. Hallam hammered Mr. Beasom for ten minutes.
While this type of scrutiny is generally a sign of an engaged board member, this problem has already been clearly stated, and restated, for years. Regardless of the reporting mechanism, the jail is still being locked down because it doesn’t have enough correctional officers. The problem has been diagnosed, but the board is not responding.
Then, instead of considering actual solutions, the board spent an hour fighting over amending the color of uniforms. While there is some evidence that different colors affect inmate mental health, the debate took over forty minutes — and ended with a vote whose results left it unclear whether the measure passed or failed.
Over the past few years, the Jail Oversight Board has been enriched by the testimony of experts and activists. Now, however, it is descending into grandstanding and parody. It’s time to take real responsibility, and to offer well-informed solutions. We hope that by the time a new permanent warden steps into that difficult role, the board will have learned how to do so.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.