Gainey administration officials continue to double-down on the brazen lie that Matrix Consulting Group satisfied the criteria for a no-bid contract by being the sole provider of city-data-backed public safety studies on the market. This lie, most recently repeated by Director of Communications Maria Montaño, expresses contempt for the people of Pittsburgh, and calls into question the veracity of the administration’s other public statements.
The shamelessness of such false statements calls to mind the political strategy of former President Donald Trump: lying with such recklessness that the line between fantasy and reality becomes blurred. And it must compel members of the media, other government officials, community stakeholders and the general public to wonder: If the Mayor’s Office is willing to make assertions that have already clearly been proven false, what other, less easily investigated lies has it been telling?
This week, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala announced an expanded inquiry into the city’s no-bid procurement practices, based on the Post-Gazette Editorial Board’s revelations about the Matrix police study contract. While the Gainey administration only presented the contract to City Council in June 2022, both Matrix’s own report and a Matrix employee, in response to questions from an Editorial Board member, confirm that work on the police study began in March. Besides being illegal in itself, this would mean the administration misled City Council.
Further, the expedited “waiver of competitive process” signed by Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt provided two justifications — one dubious at best, another provably false — for the waiver: that Matrix was already working with the city on police-related litigation, and that the firm is the only one to provide the requested services. Ms. Montaño repeated this debunked “sole provider” claim on Monday, in reply to Mr. Zappala’s inquiry: “Matrix remains ... the only company that would utilize actual city data to form its conclusions.”
This is not true, and city officials know it’s not true because the city commissioned just such a study from a different organization fewer than 20 years ago. In 2005, the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) produced a study of the Bureau of Police based on the city’s “computer-aided dispatch logs,” personnel information and extensive ride-along and in-person interviews. The Matrix study, by contrast, reached sweeping conclusions based in part on assumptions rather than hard data, while its California-based team spent only one day in Pittsburgh.
Further, Office of Management and Budget Director Jake Pawlak has acknowledged the IACP’s experience in this area, but argued that the city had other reasons to prefer Matrix. But this is irrelevant, and provides no excuse for lying, both in signed documents and public statements, about whether Matrix is the sole provider of data-backed public safety studies. It isn’t.
Mr. Zappala certainly sees impugning the Matrix study, which recommended decreasing patrol officers by one-third, as an opportunity to burnish his law-and-order credentials during a re-election campaign. But that doesn’t detract from the legitimacy of his inquiry into a deceptive and possibly corrupt procurement process. And it mustn’t distract from the habit of brazen lying that has formed in City Hall.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.