The Fern Hollow Bridge collapsed on January 28, 2022, 20 minutes before 7 a.m. But the state’s only Urban Search and Rescue Task Force, PA-TF1, along with its K-9 capabilities, didn’t arrive on the scene until after 4 p.m. That’s because the task force is located in Philadelphia — nearly five hours away.
This Wednesday, the Pennsylvania Senate Veterans Affairs and Emergency Preparedness Committee will consider a bill to expand search and rescue capabilities in Western Pennsylvania and across the wider region. This expansion would fill a geographic gap in the search and rescue network.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency first established its network of Urban Search and Rescue, or US&R, Task Forces in 1989. There are now 28 “Type 1” groups, including PA-TF1, which can scramble a 70-member team at a moment’s notice. These can be deployed piecemeal in-state, as happened after the Frick Park bridge collapse, or wholesale across the country, as happens during major disasters, such as hurricanes.
After the September 11 terrorist attacks, Pennsylvania leaders decided the state should have its own US&R system, and established smaller units, generally 10-member teams, across the commonwealth. One of the largest of these groups is the Western Pennsylvania Regional US&R, also known as Pennsylvania Strike Team 1, or simply PA-ST1. This unit, headquartered in Allegheny County, can assemble a 22-member team and fulfills the criteria for a FEMA Type 4 US&R Task Force.
Besides the Fern Hollow Bridge incident, the most notable deployments of PA-ST1 were structural collapses: Washington, Pa., in 2017 and Penn Hills in 2022. In both the Washington and Fern Hollow disasters, the team’s lack of a K-9 element hampered its response. K-9 search specialists can discover trapped people in tight spaces in a way no human can.
Between Type 4 and Type 1 US&R squads, there is Type 3. (For some reason, there is no Type 2.) A Type 3 Task Force can scramble a team of up to 35 members, and always includes K-9, medical, structural and other specialists that Type 4 squads lack. The bill under consideration in the state Senate would establish a state-organized Type 3 unit in Allegheny County, likely headquartered with the Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire. Pennsylvania Strike Team 1 would become Task Force 2.
This would fill a serious geographic gap in the US&R system: The closest large task force to Pittsburgh is actually in southwest Ohio. A new Pittsburgh team would not only be available for fast deployment in southwest Pennsylvania. It would be the closest team for most of West Virginia and western New York.
With Western Pennsylvania’s surfeit of deteriorating structures, both buildings and infrastructure, and vulnerability to flooding, it only makes sense for the region to have a fully outfitted Urban Search and Rescue team at hand. It’s a small upgrade that could pay huge dividends in lives saved.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.