As sure as fall brings excited posts about the Steelers’ prospects and depressed ones about the Pirates’ season, one of the area’s biggest debates reappears as well: Should deer be culled? But 2023 brings a new twist. The City of Pittsburgh, having answered that question with an emphatic yes, will send archers to cull deer in Frick and Riverview parks this autumn.
City Council approved the pilot program this week. The memes have been snowballing ever since. Could this become a reality competition television show, perhaps? Could everyone involved be forced to speak in pseudo-medieval language, forsooth, mayhap?
Even the New York Post found the call for Pittsburgh’s archers worthy of attention, perhaps because it mistakenly believes the archers will be chosen “randomly.” One imagines Mayor Gainey strolling around Oakland, handing 30 lucky undergrads a bow and quiver. (The Post misunderstands the lottery that will be used to select from qualified applicants.)
The program’s not a novel one. Allegheny County has hosted controlled hunts in all nine of its parks, running some of them for several decades. Other cities, including Cleveland, have used hunts to cull their overpopulation of deer.
The reality is that the number of deer in the city needs to be radically reduced, and the only efficient way to reduce the number is to cull them. The deer population has reached “a tipping point,” according to Lisa Frank, the city’s chief operating and administrative officer. The deer are a significant hazard to human and animal safety and to the environment.
In 2018, 335 deceased deer were removed from the city’s roadways; in 2021, the number rose to 510. It will continue to grow, and there’s no way to keep track of the accidents they cause that don’t result in a deer’s demise. Deer also eat native plants we want to preserve. Their consumption of local vegetation increases the risk of landslides. And deer harbor ticks that spread lyme disease. Too many deer in our city is a serious problem.
In fact, the one flaw with the city’s bow-hunters-to-the-rescue plan is that it doesn’t go far enough. Experts suggest that 80% of a deer population must be culled in order to prevent further spread. If that goal isn’t met, the deer population will likely double or triple over the next two to three years.
Not only should this continue, but programs that would sterilize the deer, cull the does more specifically, and otherwise keep the population from growing should also be considered.
For now, forsooth, yinz archers: thy time has come.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.