An unelected city planning official is twisting or outright ignoring city code in order to impede the expansion of Bakery Square in Larimer and East Liberty. Documents and correspondence reviewed by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board reveal that Zoning Administrator Corey Layman, who acts under the authority of Mayor Ed Gainey, is testing and likely exceeding the limits of his authority under city law.
At issue is the arcane process of shepherding zoning adjustments and preliminary development plans through the city’s bureaucracy, including the Department of City Planning and the separate Planning Commission. City law imposes duties on the Zoning Administrator, a city employee who serves at the pleasure of the mayor, to schedule hearings in front of the Planning Commission in a timely manner. Mr. Layman is declining to do so for the Bakery Square project.
As mayor, Mr. Gainey has the authority and the obligation to tell his officials to stop obstructing and to do their jobs under the law. If, on the other hand, Mr. Gainey approves of or directed Mr. Layman’s actions, then the Mayor is culpable, as well.
Whether the Bakery Square expansion is a good idea or not, both the property owner and the people of Pittsburgh, whose representatives on City Council are considering the zoning change, deserve a fair and legal consideration of the development. If unelected bureaucrats can ignore the law by unilaterally torpedoing projects, they are the ones really in charge.
A legal obligation
In the case of the Bakery Square expansion, on July 5 of this year City Council first transmitted a bill to City Planning for a Special Planning District for the land — currently occupied by Trader Joe’s grocery store and the Village of Eastside shopping center — adjacent to the original Bakery Square. Council followed up by transmitting the required map on July 11. The SP designation would extend the original Bakery Square district to accommodate ambitious plans by Walnut Capital, which owns both sites.
City law indicates that the Zoning Administrator, “promptly” after receiving such a bill, “shall schedule public hearing dates before the Planning Commission.” However, in correspondence with the office of City Councilman Rev. Ricky Burgess obtained by the Editorial Board, Mr. Layman indicated he had no intention to do so.
Further, Mr. Layman essentially demanded that Council request an extension to the 90-day deadline for the Planning Commission to render a decision, in order to avoid an automatic rejection — or “deemed denial” — of the proposal. A Planning Commission denial can only be overridden by seven votes on the nine-member council, which can be hard to achieve: A “deemed denial” can be fatal to a development plan.
Because of the required public notice period and the established Planning Commission meeting schedule, Mr. Layman has until Sep. 12 to schedule the hearing and make public notice — not a simple matter, given the number of property owners who must be informed “by mail and posting.”
Untenable loopholes
In a quirk of the city code, despite the Zoning Administrator’s clear duty to schedule a public hearing, the Planning Commission “may choose not to conduct a hearing.” But this is not the loophole it appears.
As part of the Special Planning District, Walnut Capital submitted a Preliminary Land Development Plan (PLDP). City law states that the Planning Commission “shall hold” a hearing once a PLDP is submitted, and that it shall occur “concurrently with the public hearing on the rezoning application.” In other words, the PLDP removes the commission’s discretion, and imposes a legal duty to give the development — the property owner’s plan in combination with City Council’s zoning amendment — due consideration.
Another possible loophole is that the 90-day approval clock begins “upon [the Zoning Administrator] determining that an application is complete,” so Mr. Layman could wait indefinitely to make such a determination. This is simply dishonest, and sets the same precedent: A single bureaucrat arbitrarily determining the fate of development and property rights. It cannot be allowed to stand.
Mr. Layman did not respond to an email and phone call seeking comment.
Rule by bureaucrat
It is possible to believe that Walnut Capital’s planned expansion of Bakery Square, at least in its current form, would not be in the best interests of the city. But it cannot be denied that Walnut Capital has fulfilled its obligations under the law. In fact, in striking a Community Benefits Agreement with the Larimer Consensus Group, the company has gone beyond what the law requires.
The CBA promises $25 million — $6 million from Walnut plus a pledged $19 million from other sources, likely the development’s lessees — for housing in the neighborhood. The $19 million commitment is non-binding, however, and City Council should strengthen the deal by placing Walnut on the hook for any funds it fails to secure.
What’s at stake here, however, is more than the fate of a few acres in the East End. It’s whether the people of Pittsburgh can count on their government to fulfill its obligations under the law. And it’s the question of who, really, is in charge.
Whether Mr. Layman is obstructing the process for his own reasons or at Mr. Gainey’s behest is not yet known. Regardless, it is the duty of the Mayor to uphold the rule of law, including and especially among his own officials. There is no legal reason to hold the Bakery Square expansion hostage: It deserves an honest hearing and fair vote of the Planning Commission. And there is no good reason to give one bureaucrat the power to deny that right, to flout the law and to defy City Council.
Clarification: The original version of this editorial misstated the nature of City Council’s referral of the zoning amendment to the Department of City Planning. Council’s “transmitted” the bill to the department for its consideration in anticipation of a vote for full approval.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.