A rough arrest on Smithfield Street last Friday evening, videotaped and shared on social media by a local activist, was the predictable result of policies pursued by the Gainey administration to lean on Pittsburgh police to clean up Downtown — after an 18-month delay in calling a new academy class left the bureau understaffed.

With officers having to work regular double shifts and given an unclear mandate from City Hall to police not just law-breaking but mental health and homelessness, it was inevitable the Downtown beat would become the scene of controversy.

Even so, these circumstances cannot justify or excuse any violations of procedure in the arrest of Jashon Martin. The fact that no officers have been placed on administrative leave strongly suggests that the city has thus far determined that no violations took place. If that is the case, the city should say so.

Further, as an expression of trust in the community, and as a demonstration of transparency early in the tenure of Chief Larry Scirotto, the Department of Public Safety should release body-camera footage from the incident. The activist’s video and the officers’ report each tell part of the story: Body-camera footage can complete the picture, so Pittsburghers can more fully understand the incident and the city’s response to it.

Advertise with us

Smithfield scuffle

According to police, around 6 p.m. officers observed Mr. Martin fight with another man along Smithfield Street, then return to the scene in the evening seemingly looking for the same man. His attire and posture, police say, suggested he was trying to conceal a weapon and his identity. Officers also reported seeing Mr. Martin trade in drugs.

The video of the arrest shows several officers attempting to subdue Mr. Martin. Once officers force him to the sidewalk, they warn that he is reaching for his waistband. The police report indicates that a fixed-blade knife was recovered from the scene.

During the scuffle to get Mr. Martin’s arms behind his back, an officer delivers three jabs to his face, but another officer restrains his colleague from continuing. The punching officer also exclaims that Mr. Martin had bit him. The final restraining of Mr. Martin occurs when another officer delivers a hard knee to his midsection.

It was an ugly scene in the way that any arrest that requires the use of force is ugly. While the jabs and especially the knee may look like abuse, the activist’s video does not give the full context of the scuffle. Body-camera footage would help the public evaluate the officers’ claims about Mr. Martin’s behavior, and the city’s decision in the matter.

Advertise with us

Downtown dragnet

Last Friday’s incident occurred in the wider context of the city’s attempt to reassure residents and visitors that Downtown is clean and safe. Despite having campaigned on a public safety reform platform, and despite inattentiveness to the personnel crisis unfolding at the police bureau, Mr. Gainey has chosen to rely primarily on police for this task.

The Gainey administration inherited the institutional infrastructure for a more holistic approach to Downtown security, but has chosen not to use it. This is clearest in the sidelining of the Office of Community Health and Safety (OCHS), including the public safety-social worker co-response programs it developed in 2020.

This is particularly ironic given Mr. Gainey’s consistent references to violence as a “public health” problem. The Mayor and his team have never explained what exactly that means, but apparently it does not mean using the public health approaches already in place.

The Gainey administration has also failed to execute a $10 million expansion of the Reaching Out On The Streets (ROOTS) collaboration with the Allegheny Health Network — while still reporting the $10 million in federal funds earmarked for it as “expended.” The money would have expanded ROOTS mental-health outreach to more neighborhoods, while also supporting the Community Outreach Hub on Smithfield Street, a block from last Friday’s incident.

Advertise with us

Having rejected a comprehensive public health and safety response to Downtown, Mr. Gainey has turned to an already overtaxed and understaffed police department — one that, as of last Friday, still had about 50 officers on leave after discharging their service weapons during the Garfield shootout and standoff.

Ragged response

Thus far, the Gainey administration’s response has been disjointed, including promising a statement on the incident earlier this week that, as of Wednesday evening, has not materialized. The administration explained that city leaders met Tuesday to decide what form an investigation should take, but inquiries into police use of force are strictly defined by law and policy, and don’t need to be invented on the fly.

This incident has placed Mr. Gainey and his team in an unenviable political situation. In the immediate aftermath of the Smithfield incident, the Black Political Empowerment Project, the NAACP Pittsburgh Branch and the Alliance for Police Accountability released a joint statement expressing “outrage” at what they labeled, based on the viral video, “extreme and unjustifiable force.” But with no officers yet on leave, the city seems to have quietly determined otherwise.

Stuck between organizations that have supported him and the apparent evidence, Mr. Gainey must decide his next move. The simplest and best is to put politics aside and to tell the public the truth about what the city has determined — and to release the body-camera videos that back it up.