Wednesday’s shootout and standoff in Garfield endangered the lives of dozens of neighbors and law enforcement officers. As more information trickles in about the gunman — and his previous interactions with law enforcement and other city authorities — in the coming days and weeks, there must be a comprehensive and transparent accounting of how such a dangerously unstable situation developed.

Specifically, city and county officials must look closely at their programs and policies to understand what interventions were attempted, how they failed, and whether new programs and procedures are necessary to help — or to stop — people who are spiraling out of control.

Because a war-zone shootout like this cannot be allowed to happen again.

No easy answers

Advertise with us

It is far too early to draw comprehensive lessons from the tragic story of William Hardison. But from what we already know, we can arrive at one clear conclusion: This incident, and the years that led up to it, does not fit any simple ideological narrative.

As of this writing, information continues to accumulate, but much of it is sketchy. Here we will relate only what can be known for sure as of Friday afternoon.

Hardison was living in a Garfield house that did not, as a matter of law, belong to him. The modest Broad Street townhouse had belonged to his brother, Joseph, until his death in 2021. Earlier this year, a limited liability corporation named 907 East Street purchased the home for $25,000, and sought to evict Hardison in May. He refused to leave, and so 907 East Street received a court order for his ejection at 10:30 a.m. on August 23.

Hardison had written numerous statements on the front of the house that asserted his rights to the property, and his antipathy for police. Law enforcement indicated in the aftermath that they did not expect the level of resistance they received, but neighbors did notice Hardison collecting worrying supplies, like gasoline. The fact that seven sheriff’s deputies arrived on Wednesday morning for the ejection was unusual, and indicates that Hardison was considered a potentially difficult subject.

For some time, Hardison had identified with the Moorish sovereign citizen movement, whose adherents assert that they are not subject to the laws of the United States. Over the last 20 years, he had amassed 42 criminal charges or citations, mostly for vehicle violations, such as driving an unregistered and uninsured vehicle without a license. It is clear that, as a matter of principle, he did not recognize the authority of the law.

Advertise with us

The die had been cast

Given what we know of Hardison’s beliefs and the arsenal he had collected, it is fair to say that by the time deputies arrived at 4817 Broad Street on Wednesday morning, the result was preordained. Law enforcement, as well as neighbors, report that he began firing as soon as officers entered the house. De-escalation was no longer an option.

By the end of the ordeal more than 70 law enforcement officers, including nearly 50 Pittsburgh police officers, had fired their weapons. At least half a dozen agencies had participated. Thousands of rounds had ricocheted through the neighborhood.

This suggests a level of chaos that put many neighbors in danger: It is a miracle no one but Hardison was seriously injured. Pittsburgh and Allegheny County police should closely study this incident to determine what procedures need to be tightened to ensure a disciplined approach to such engagements.

More importantly, however, authorities at every level need to study this episode to understand how it got to the point where bloodshed was inevitable. That never should have happened, and it mustn’t happen again.

Advertise with us

Early interventions

From both a law-enforcement and a social-services perspective, the events of Wednesday must be seen as a failure. Once seven armed deputies have arrived at a house in order to drag a person out, whether or not he has an arsenal, multiple systems have broken down. Several questions must be answered to understand how to avoid this outcome in the future.

It is clear that Hardison was on the radar of law enforcement for years. Did the city Department of Public Safety ever communicate concerns about him to other agencies, in the city, the county or the private sector, that specialize in social services and mental-health interventions? Did any agency offer resources for alternative housing not just in anticipation of Hardison’s ejection, but at any time during his squatting?

It is possible, even likely, that Hardison’s peculiar beliefs would have prohibited him from accepting any of this assistance. Those same beliefs led him to live, essentially, outside the law for at least the past several years. Multiple driver’s license offenses usually result in fines and even incarceration, especially if the fines go unpaid — which we can assume they did, unless someone covered him. Why did none of Hardison’s citations result in any real consequences? And despite his record, how did he collect so many guns?

Wednesday’s violent chaos was the last-resort outcome that should have been avoided at all costs. William Hardison may have been the hardest of hard cases, but at some point there must have been an off-ramp. Going back and finding it will help ensure something like this never happens again.