Twelve jurors have sentenced Robert Bowers, 50, of Baldwin, to die for having committed the worst act of antisemitic violence in American history. While this board has argued that justice is not best served by a lengthy capital trial — today’s verdict now triggers years of appeals — now we place the focus where it belongs: on the people who were murdered while they worshipped; on those who were injured and carry the scars of hatred on their bodies; and on the families whose wounds will never fully heal.

The people who were killed

Here are some of the painful and beautiful words spoken by loved ones during the victim statement portion of the trial, as recorded by the Post-Gazette’s Megan Guza, who chronicled the courtroom proceedings over the past three-and-a-half months.

Joyce Fienberg, 75: “She meant everything to the kids,” said son Anthony. “Our kids were devastated. We always talk about her. We always make reference to the good times. We try to bring up all of those positive memories but you can’t fill the hole.”

Advertise with us

Richard Gottfried, 65: “Half of me was gone,” said wife Peg Durachko. Richard had a motto: “We’re going to do this while we can.” She reminisced on the witness stand, “I’m so glad he said that. At least I have those memories.”

Rose Mallinger, 97: “Now she doesn’t get to play games, she doesn’t get to dance at my wedding,” said granddaughter Amy. She contemplated calling her grandmother’s phone number, still programmed into her phone, in the hope that she might answer. But she knew it was impossible.

Jerry Rabinowitz, 66: “I can’t remember a time he wasn’t smiling,” said brother-in-law Daniel Kramer. Jerry’s wife, Miri, still cannot speak about her loss, so Daniel spoke for her: “My sister wakes up in the house she lived in with Jerry for 30 years and he’s not there. When she goes to sleep at night, he’s not there.”

Cecil, 59, and David Rosenthal, 54: “Our hearts are empty every single day knowing our sons are gone forever,” said father Eliezer. “Our family will never be the same.” Cecil, he said, is forever 59. David, forever 54. They were killed in “a place they felt welcome and safe.”

Bernice, 84, and Sylvan Simon, 86: “She was my best friend,” said daughter Michelle Weis of Bernice. “She was my person I would call, vent to, just talk to. Now I can’t do that.” Son Michael added: “You just have a void. It’s like you have a hole in your heart that’s never going to heal.”

Advertise with us

Daniel Stein, 71: “People gravitated to him,” said wife Sharyn. “He liked a good laugh.” Son Joseph reflected on a feeling shared by all the families: “I didn’t ask for this. No one asked for this.”

Melvin Wax, 88: “I think of him every day,” said daughter Jodi Kart. When she visited Melvin’s apartment after the murders, she found a birthday card he had prepared for her on his nightstand. In it she found the words, “I love you very much.”

Irving Younger, 69: “Anytime we went somewhere, it always felt like a first date,” said girlfriend Judith Kaye. “It took me 60 years to meet him. He was the late love of my life.”

The people who were injured

In addition to the eleven lives taken, six people suffered injuries at the hands of the shooter. Their names are congregants Dan Leger and Andrea Wedner, and Officers Anthony Burke, Timothy Matson, Daniel Mead and Michael Smidga of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police.

Advertise with us

Mr. Leger suffered terrible pain from being shot in the abdomen and endured several surgeries. He has been unable to return to the job he loved, serving as a hospital chaplain.

Ms. Wedner’s arm was destroyed by the gunfire, and her surgeries are still not over. She, too, has been unable to return to work.

Mr. Smidga was struck by shrapnel and cut across his face.

Mr. Mead lost the use of his hand and much of the use of his legs. He required a wheelchair in the courtroom.

Mr. Burke was also shot in the hand. He was able to return to work, but the physical and psychological pain lingers.

Advertise with us

Mr. Matson was shot several times, and spent 16 weeks in three different hospitals recovering. But he survived, and waters a plant — a simple weed — on his front porch to remind himself of value of sustaining life.

The people who endure

Today’s verdict brings to a close this portion of the shooting’s aftermath, a full four-and-a-half excruciating years later. But it is just another signpost in the long process of healing and closure for the families and friends of the killed and injured; for the community they share; and for the city that stands in solidarity with them.

They stand — and we must all stand — as a living rebuke to the hatred that seeks to exterminate the joy and hope and compassion of the Jewish people, who are defined by their endurance over the millennia. That is the task, always and for all people: to continue to love, to hope, to mourn, to play, to share — in short, to live — together, so that the darkness does not prevail.