Irregularities in the procurement process for Pittsburgh’s police staffing study, revealed last week by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, have prompted not just an investigation, but smart proposals from City Council to reform a system that places too much power in, or near, the mayor’s office.

Over the past several years, changes to city law have concentrated control over procurement, including approving exceptions to procurement rules, in the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). The OMB’s director is appointed by the mayor and works closely with the mayor’s office.

The result is a circular system with little oversight: The procurement office within OMB oversees the process, but can also unilaterally waive its own regulations. For instance, the suspicious Waiver of Competitive Process that led to Matrix Consulting Group getting a no-bid contract to study the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police was signed first by Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt, then approved by OMB’s Chief Procurement Officer Jennifer Olzinger. No one outside Mayor Ed Gainey’s purview had a say.

Ideally, City Council would have scrutinized the waiver, but when the resolution appeared in June 2022 there was still a trusting relationship between the legislature and the Gainey administration. More importantly, however, council has neither the time nor the resources to investigate each of the documents that accompany the dozens of appropriations resolutions it handles.

Advertise with us

A vulnerable system

This is where the independent Office of the City Controller should step in. While the controller approves every contract the city enters into, there’s no rule the office must scrutinize competitive bid waivers, and no sign it currently does so. This leaves the system vulnerable to carelessness and malfeasance.

Councilors Ricky Burgess and Anthony Coghill have sponsored a bill that would ensure the City Controller joins OMB in signing off on all Waivers of Competitive Process. The ordinance would also require that the controller and the City Solicitor sign off on two particularly easy-to-abuse justifications for bid waivers: contracts that relate to “anticipated, pending or potential litigation” or “a court order, grant, collective bargaining agreement or governmental order.”

This is a savvy response that should avoid future problems, like the Matrix fiasco, which council has rightly asked the Solicitor’s Office to review. The waiver submitted by the Gainey administration included one false statement, and another which revealed a potentially illicit pre-existing relationship with the consultant.

Late last Friday, implicitly in response to the Post-Gazette’s editorial revealing these irregularities, Mr. Gainey tweeted that he will “stand in solidarity” with the roughly one-third of union newsroom employees who are on strike “by not offering comment for any story the paper publishes.” In other words, the mayor is casting his refusal to address substantiated allegations of his administration’s misconduct as a virtue. It won’t work.

After all, even if he refuses to respond to this newspaper, he must respond to the other branches of city government who read it, and take action based on its work.