Incoming Pittsburgh Chief of Police Larry Scirotto has quietly replaced the Bureau’s four assistant chiefs — two white women, one Black woman and a Black man — with three white men. The Bureau did not announce the shakeup publicly, or even tell City Council, since it happened two weeks ago.

The competence and professionalism of the new group of chiefs are not in question. All appear well-qualified and able to help lead the department, though the appointments raise questions about Mr. Scirotto’s public commitment to a more diverse police force. Moreover, making the appointments without notice is not the way to run an open and transparent department. It is more in keeping with the closed manner in which the administration of Mayor Ed Gainey has run the city.

There’s nothing unusual or untoward about a new chief installing his preferred assistants. What should concern Pittsburghers is that Mr. Scirotto and Mr. Gainey didn’t inform the public about about a significant change in the Bureau’s leadership.

Out are Assistant Chief Philip Carey, Assistant Chief of Operations Anna Kudrav, Assistant Chief of Investigations Lavonnie Bickerstaff and Assistant Chief of Administration Linda Barone. The latter three are still listed on the Bureau’s website, but sources have confirmed to the Post-Gazette editorial board that they are no longer serving in those roles.

Advertise with us

The new acting assistant chiefs are Richard Ford in Operations, Martin Devine in Investigations and Chris Ragland in Administration. Mr. Ford and Mr. Devine were promoted to commander in 2021, with Mr. Ford assigned to major crimes and Mr. Devine assigned to narcotics and vice. Mr. Ragland was appointed by former mayor Bill Peduto to lead the Bureau’s Office of Strategy, Accountability and Resiliency, and has recently been involved with enhancing the police presence Downtown.

The only hint of the shakeup came on Twitter on Monday, when the Pittsburgh Public Safety account posted a video of Mr. Ford speaking at a SWAT scene in Arlington and identified him as “Acting Assistant Chief of Operations.” Mr. Ford’s remarks to the media drew praise online for their clarity and candor, and sources indicate that he is well-regarded on the force. His promotion, along with Mr. Ragland’s and Mr. Devine’s, does not raise any red flags in itself.

The three men’s leaders in the Bureau and the Mayor’s Office, however, have done them no favors by sliding them into their new roles without public notice. If they are the best officers for the jobs, Mr. Scirotto and Mr. Gainey should have stood up and made their case to the people of Pittsburgh, while renewing their commitment to an open and diverse police department.