The City of Pittsburgh’s plan to float a high-interest bond to fund undefined affordable housing projects is a scandalously irresponsible use of taxpayer resources. After several years of progress out of Act 47 “distressed” status and into financial responsibility, Mayor Ed Gainey and City Council seem determined to reverse course.

The question is not whether the city should fund programs to ensure housing is available to people of all income levels: It should, and should do so generously. The question is how to do so in a way that is effective, including cost-effective.

Floating a bond, which will cost tens of millions of dollars in interest alone, while free federal money remains unspent — and after rejecting a $40 million corporate commitment — can reflect only incompetence or a malicious disregard for the citizens who fund city government.

A (nearly) blank check

Advertise with us

In early June, the Urban Redevelopment Authority announced its intention to seek up to $42 million in debt financing for affordable housing. But it needed council to approve a transfer of city funds to the authority, so it could bring that commitment to the bond market. That is the $62.5 million over 25 years, or $2.5 million per year, council approved on Tuesday by an 8 to 1 vote.

But the authority refused to give City Council any details about how the money would be spent, explaining lamely that it might negatively impact the pricing of the bond. Council should not have tolerated the dodge: It’s their responsibility as the people’s representatives to find out what the people’s money is being spent on.

Council also couldn’t ascertain how much debt the city’s $62.5 million investment will actually buy. The best the URA could do is offer an absurdly wide range of $25 million to $42 million. In other words, the city will be on the hook for between $20 million and nearly $40 million in interest payments — and council has given up its ability to object if the URA accepts ruinous terms.

It is a normal feature of public finance to take on debt, and to pay a discouraging amount servicing that debt. But Pittsburgh already has tens of millions in free, expiring federal funds set aside for affordable housing. It is absurdly irresponsible to take out expensive debt while the administration struggles to spend the money it already has.

Wasting free money

Advertise with us

The same administration that is looking to raise $42 million in debt for housing has $41 million in federal pandemic relief (ARPA) funds set aside for housing. All of that was originally slated to be spent in 2021 and 2022. But according to the city’s April filing, thus far it has spent only $110,000. Anything left over at the end of 2025 will be forfeit.

The current ARPA plan includes more than $15 million for the OwnPGH program, which provides grants to first-time homebuyers to help them land a place in the city, as well as $5 million to support a community land trust and $4 million for development through the Pittsburgh Housing Development Corporation. It is almost all unspent.

In fact, the most recent revision to the city’s ARPA plan, introduced in City Council by the mayor’s office on Tuesday, would remove more than $5 million in housing support for utilities and financial counseling. In other words, Mr. Gainey is looking to remove free money from housing, while he replaces it with debt.

Meanwhile, the URA spent far less on affordable housing in the first year of Mr. Gainey’s term — $12.7 million for 511 units — than it did in the final two years of Bill Peduto’s administration — $65 million for 2,000 units.

There was never a plan

Advertise with us

The federal money isn’t the only painful missed opportunity to invest in affordable housing. Mr. Peduto negotiated a $40 million contribution, earmarked for affordable housing, from UPMC as part of his OnePGH program. Mr. Gainey turned that money away.

This board was skeptical of Mr. Peduto’s scheme, especially because he sold OnePGH as an investment in the city when an independent board controlled its resources. It was an imperfect arrangement, and we said nothing when Mr. Gainey ended it, assuming that an alternative would be in the offing.

Instead, the mayor spurned $40 million he has not replaced. That money could have housed many Pittsburghers and measurably improved the quality of life in the city. There's no excuse for giving up this funding without being able to replace it.

And now the taxpayers will be on the hook for $20 million to $40 million in debt service to fill that gap.

This episode is yet another example of a mayoral administration struggling with basic governance — this time, aided and abetted by City Council. If the city’s legislature doesn’t soon begin to perform its duty to hold the mayor accountable, it will be just as responsible as Ed Gainey for the consequences.

Correction: The original version of this editorial incorrectly identified the recipient of $4 million in affordable housing funding. It is the Pittsburgh Housing Development Corporation.