The main justification for the United States’ continuing financial and material support for Ukraine’s defense is a moral claim: that Vladimir Putin’s Russia has committed a gross violation of international law, human rights and basic morality that cannot be rewarded with success. That argument lost much of its force when President Joe Biden embraced Mr. Putin’s immorality by authorizing the transfer of cluster bombs to Ukraine.
Cluster munitions release thousands of battery-sized “bomblets” from high altitude, which explode over several acres. Many bomblets fail to detonate when they reach the ground, littering the terrain with shiny explosives that endure for decades, and attract children because they often look like toys. The New Republic reports that in 2021 unexploded cluster bomblets killed or maimed 141 people: 97% were civilians, and two-thirds of them children. Children 10 years from now may be dying or maimed by the bombs the U.S. is supplying.
That’s why 123 nations, including almost every close ally of the U.S., have signed an agreement condemning these brutal weapons as wrong for mankind to use. The United Kingdom, Germany and other European countries refuse to supply them to Ukraine.
America did not sign the treaty, but last deployed cluster munitions in 2006, and began decommissioning them in 2016 due to the threat to civilians. Last February, then-White House press secretary Jen Psaki described reported Russian cluster bomb deployment as a possible war crime. How did they become acceptable since then?
Russia and Ukraine are also not signatories to the agreement, and international watchdog Human Rights Watch has documented use by both sides in civilian areas, with Russian offenses especially flagrant. This has led many commentators to argue that Russia’s use of cluster bombs not only justifies but necessitates the United States give Ukraine the means to reply in kind. Some argue that the only reason to oppose these weapons is sympathy with Vladimir Putin.
Quite the opposite: In adopting Mr. Putin’s ends-justify-the-means morality, Mr. Biden not only endorses a form of warfare most of the world condemns as a violation of international law, he plays into into the tyrant’s hands. It’s a strategic as well as a moral failure.
Sending American cluster bombs to Ukraine lends credibility to Mr. Putin’s argument that the West’s claim to the moral high ground is not just unwarranted, but cynical and opportunistic. Worse, reflexively responding to an enemy in kind allows the enemy to justify that and similar actions it feels it needs to take in the future. It endorses a moral principle that could be used to justify anything — as long as it is deemed necessary to win, especially if the enemy does it first. It could justify tactical nuclear weapons.
Stooping to the level of an amoral opponent is not the act of a confident world power, and no battlefield advantage justifies knowingly putting civilians, especially children, at risk for decades to come.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.