Pennsylvania’s archaic alcohol laws have driven license prices so high that the system keeps would-be restaurant and bar owners from opening the local places that mean so much to communities, and favors large corporations like supermarket chains. This must change.

This is one of the few states with a market in liquor licenses. In most places, applying for permission to serve alcohol is like getting a permit to renovate a property, but in Pennsylvania alcohol licenses are like the famous taxicab medallions in New York City: an artificially scarce resource that creates a huge barrier to entering the industry. In Allegheny County, demand for licenses after the pandemic has driven up prices to six figures.

Officially, the state allots one bar or restaurant alcohol license (called an “R” license) per 3,000 residents. In reality, the licenses issued before the cap was instituted in 1939 continue to exist, which means that some counties have many more licenses than the quota would allow. Allegheny has 1,468 for a county of about 1.25 million people, or about one per 850 residents.

Even so, the quota system has driven prices up. Any county over the quota can’t add any new licenses, meaning anyone looking to open a new establishment has to buy an existing license from its current owner. Over time the number of licenses in the county has ratcheted down, as they are revoked or allowed to lapse, increasing the price.

Advertise with us

In 2016, the General Assembly smartly created an auction system to allow licenses that “died” since 2000 to be brought back to market, the first infusion of “new” licenses into many counties in nearly eight decades. But the price is still very high.

In the past few years, Philadelphia Magazine reports, the entrance of grocery and convenience stores into the “R” license market has driven up prices, and the companies gobble up licenses that could have been used by a neighborhood bar or restaurant. In Philadelphia and its collar counties, prices regularly hit a quarter of a million dollars. The record price is $556,000, paid by the Giant supermarket chain at a public auction in Cumberland County.

These prices make opening a small neighborhood watering hole — the kind of establishment that brings people together across all the usual lines — almost impossible for most would-be bar owners. The system skews the market in favor of the very biggest players. It also protects established interests: Current license-holders don’t want to see their investment diluted by a wave of new licenses, which would crush the market price of what is often their most valuable asset.

One way to improve the system, proposed a decade ago by state Rep. Dan Moul, R-Adams, would be to create a new class of license that would allow an establishment to sell only wine or beer. These cheaper licenses would allow local entrepreneurs to open smaller neighborhood bars and restaurants without diluting the investments of current license-holders too much. This idea would also raise money for the state.

That’s not enough to encourage the creation of the small local institutions upon which communities depend, but it’s a start.