In the years leading up to the American Revolution, Pennsylvania lawyer John Dickinson wrote some of the most widely read pamphlets that expressed the colonists’ grievances against Great Britain. His 12 “Letters from a Farmer,” published in 1767 and 1768, earned him the nickname “Penman of the Revolution.” Voltaire compared them to the work of Cicero.
Dickinson was always a moderate revolutionary — if he could be called a revolutionary at all. He didn’t relish the idea of conflict with the mother country, but he also could not tolerate assaults on the rights and privileges of Englishmen. He did not sign the Declaration of Independence, but he drafted the Articles of Confederation and did sign the Constitution.
What is apparent throughout Dickinson’s writing, and exemplified in this excerpt, is his emphasis on principle. He understood that the extent of a violation of a principle does not matter: Whether the breach is large or small, what matters is the principle. And once it has been violated without consequence, it withers.
The following selection is taken from Letter VII, in response to the Townshend Acts, which placed duties on certain imports the colonies were forced to buy from Britain. This amounted to a tax on people who lacked representation in Parliament, violating a principle of the unwritten constitution of the mother country.
The final paragraph, however, also highlights a gaping blind spot — a paradox and hypocrisy in not only Dickinson’s principles, but also the theorems of the Founders in general: He calls the Englishmen of the colonies “slaves” to Parliament because they were taxed without consent, while ignoring the plight of the African slaves he kept, whose suffering was far worse and denial of rights far more egregious. The English writer Samuel Johnson pointed out this inconsistency at the heart of the American project, noting the “loudest yelps for liberty” came from slave owners.
John Dickinson eventually understood this as well. He later freed his slaves unconditionally, and contributed to abolitionist causes before his death in 1808.
Happy Independence Day.
Letters from a Farmer, no. 7
Some persons may think this act of no consequence, because the duties are so small. A fatal error. That is the very circumstance most alarming to me. For I am convinced that the authors of this law, would never have obtained an act to raise so trifling a sum . . . had they not intended by it to establish a precedent for future use. To console ourselves with the smallness of the duties, is to walk deliberately into the snare that is set for us, praising the neatness of the workmanship. Suppose the duties, imposed by the late act, could be paid by these distressed colonies, with the utmost ease, and that the purposes, to which they are to be applied, were the most reasonable and equitable that could be conceived . . . yet even in such a supposed case, these colonies ought to regard the act with abhorrence. For who are a free people? not those over whom government is reasonably and equitably exercised but those who live under a government, so constitutionally checked and (controlled) that proper provision is made against its being otherwise exercised. The late act is founded on the destruction of this constitutional security.
If the parliament have a right to lay a duty of four shillings and eight pence on a hundred weight of glass, or a ream of paper, they have a right to lay a duty of any other sum on either. They may raise the duty as . . . has been done in some countries, till it “exceeds seventeen or eighteen times the value of the commodity.” In short, if they have a right to levy a tax of one penny upon us, they have a right to levy a million upon us. For where does their right stop? At any given number of pence, shillings, or pounds? To attempt to limit their right, after granting it to exist at all, is as contrary to reason, as granting it to exist at all is contrary to justice. If they have any right to tax us, then, whether our own money shall continue in our own pockets, or not, depends no longer on us, but on them. “There is nothing which we can call our own,” or to use the words of Mr. Locke, “What property have” we “in that, which another may, by right, take, when he pleases, to himself.”
These duties, which will inevitably be levied upon us, and which are now levying upon us, are expressly laid for the sole purpose of taking money. This is the true definition of taxes. They are therefore taxes. This money is to be taken from us. We are therefore taxed. Those who are taxed without their own consent, given by themselves, or their representatives, are slaves. We are taxed without our own consent given by ourselves, or our representatives. We are therefore — I speak it with grief — I speak it with indignation — we are slaves.
John Dickinson, 1768




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.