Public urination and defecation have become more than a nuisance in downtown Pittsburgh: They’re a public health problem that’s undermining the city’s economic and social life. Something must be done.

Other cities have attempted to mitigate the same problem by installing city-owned restrooms in public places. It’s hardly the perfect solution, but the mayor and other stakeholders should seriously consider it.

After the closure of the Smithfield Street shelter, it’s more urgent than ever to make sure Pittsburgh’s growing unhoused population has a sanitary place to relieve themselves and wash up. But public restrooms aren’t just for the unhoused: Downtown Pittsburgh’s lack of public bathroom facilities can keep visitors, especially older adults and families with young children, from visiting the Golden Triangle. One recent study revealed that 14% of Downtown visitors have had to cut their visits short to find a restroom.

Without public restrooms, people can sometimes go to shops or restaurants, but access is spotty, often depending on the goodwill of the staff. This also places a burden on business owners to clean up — and police — restrooms.

Advertise with us

Public restrooms can also become havens for drug use, illegal activities and vandals.

Pittsburgh has reason to be wary. In 2003, to great fanfare, the city installed an “automatic public pay toilet” on Carson Street in the South Side. But the high-tech facility was too tempting to vandals: It remains in place but never open. The city has also experimented with basic portable toilets near Downtown shelters, but these became unsanitary havens for drug use and even sexual assaults.

Up to now, Pittsburgh’s attempts to install public restrooms have been ill-conceived and poorly executed, but there are better models to emulate.

Fifteen years ago, a Portland, Ore.-based company began manufacturing the Portland Loo, which mitigates some of the usual problems. Its stainless steel construction resists vandalism, and its open top and bottom grating provide a minimum of privacy. At $100,000 each, these public toilets are also inexpensive.

Portland Loos have not, however, met with universal success. In San Diego, the expense of connecting the restrooms to water and sewer systems more than doubled the sticker price. Owing to increased crime, the city removed one of two loos after only a year. A tour of some locations around the country shows some Loos to be clean and tidy; others are repulsive.

Advertise with us

The key to the success of the Portland Loo, and public restrooms generally, is regular maintenance and ongoing vigilance. This is not a place for half-measures. Poorly executed public restrooms will worsen the problem. If Pittsburgh considers installing them, it must also commit to funding attendants and regular police patrols.

At a public meeting about the Smithfield closure earlier this month, homeless advocates and business interests agreed on the need for Downtown bathrooms. Making them happen, however, will take both groups working together, in coordination with the city or the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, not just to build them but to keep them clean and safe for the long haul.

There must be a solution that respects the dignity and safety of everyone. With hard work and creative collaboration, Pittsburgh can find one.