The lack of communication and due process accorded Allegheny County’s growing population of unhoused people is shameful, revealing a deep-seated contempt — or, at best, an unacceptable lack of respect — for some of the community’s most vulnerable people. No other people would be treated the way the administrations of County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and Mayor Ed Gainey have treated the homeless in closing the low-barrier Smithfield Shelter downtown, and in clearing encampments on public property.
Without alternatives, Smithfield’s closing will push more unhoused people into the Downtown area — exactly what public officials and business owners don’t want. County officials have not found alternatives spots for most of Smithfield’s regular residents, and should not have closed Smithfield until they had.
An emergency shelter, Smithfield accepted people — roughly 600 a month — that other shelters wouldn’t take. Moreover, it’s unclear whether Smithfield will reopen in winter. That will be determined by the Department of Human Services later this year, a county official told a Post-Gazette editor Tuesday.
The prospect of more people in tents or makeshift camps makes a formal policy on handling them essential. The Gainey administration has effectively reversed a longstanding policy — official from 2003 to 2006, and unofficial until last year — that recognized certain due process protections for homeless people when their encampments were closed, including adequate notice and the safeguarding of their personal property.
In one jaw-dropping incident, reported in a Jan. 19, letter from the ACLU of Pennsylvania and the Community Justice Project to City Solicitor Krysia Kubiak and County Solicitor George Janocsko, a front-loader lifted a sleeping woman, still inside her tent, and dropped her six feet to the ground.
Clear policy needed
Long-term, Allegheny County needs a comprehensive policy for housing the homeless and moving as many of them as possible to independence and self-sufficiency. But it also needs, as soon as possible, clear guidelines on handling an impending housing crisis in Pittsburgh, while safeguarding the rights of the unhoused. The county and city can’t wait until they create more shelter beds to establish these policies — in fact, an acute shortage of shelter beds makes them even more necessary.
A 2003 settlement, resulting from a claim against the City of Pittsburgh and officially enforced for three years, provides a good model. It required the city to provide adequate notice before so-called cleanups, which displace tents and other living quarters. Equally important, it required the city to store any personal belongings, which could include irreplaceable photos or essential medications, for up to a year and give people an easy way to reclaim them.
Policies stipulated by the 2003 policy would serve Allegheny County well today. They should also require social service workers to make substantial efforts to relocate homeless people forced out of their living spaces, as well as to link them to services.
Long-term problem
One shelter director estimates that 2,000 to 2,500 people are homeless in the Pittsburgh area, with one-third of them needing mental health services, and hundreds of homeless children are attending area schools. Thousands more local people have experienced homelessness at some time during the last year. Allegheny County needs more emergency shelter beds, transitional housing and affordable housing units.
The shelter at Smithfield United Church of Christ typically opened during the winter only; it was not designed for year-round use. In March, however, the county said it would extends its normal operations through the summer to continue accommodating more than 100 people a night. Then, on May 22, it announced it would shut down the shelter in late June.
The closing caught even the Allegheny County Council off-guard. Communication between Allegheny County and elected officials, shelters, homeless people and the community was abysmal.
Closing shelters or moving people from one part of the city to another won’t end or alleviate homelessness in Pittsburgh. It will take a coordinated community effort by people who trust, and communicate with, each other, not only to get people safely off the streets, but also to provide the services that will move many of them to self-sufficiency and permanent housing.
Until then, however, the people of Pittsburgh should not tolerate their leaders closing encampments without adequate notice, trashing personal property or abusing the unhoused. Pittsburgh doesn’t need another image of a front-loader lifting, and dropping, a sleeping woman.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.