In not recognizing non-nurse midwives, Pennsylvania is holding back the improvement of maternity care while unnecessarily putting the growing number of women who choose home births at risk. The commonwealth should join nearly 40 other states by bringing these practitioners, also known as direct-entry midwives, into the legitimate medical system.

Midwifery is an ancient practice whose effectiveness is confirmed by modern scientific methods. The state’s posture toward it is outdated, based in early-twentieth-century over-confidence in experts and institutions, and more deeply in suspicions of women’s wisdom and competence. It’s time to leave that behind.

Alternative birth experiences

Home birth is relatively rare in the United States, accounting for about 1.25% of all live births in 2020, but that makes the U.S. an outlier compared to the rest of the world. In the Netherlands, for instance, about 20% of births take place at home, and the U.K. National Health System has encouraged healthy women with normal pregnancies — about 85% of pregnancies — to consider out-of-hospital care, whether in a birthing center or at home.

Advertise with us

Research has consistently demonstrated that home birth is at least as safe as hospital birth for uncomplicated pregnancies, with maternal outcomes in particular being better at home. For this reason, among others, the practice is growing in the U.S., including a 22% increase from 2019 to 2020 alone.

In Pennsylvania, the number of births that took place in neither a hospital nor a freestanding birthing center increased from 2,478 to 3,639, or nearly 50%, from 2010 to 2020. (There were 130,693 live births in the state in 2020.) Pennsylvania has an unusually high number of home births due to the prevalence of Plain communities, such as Amish and Mennonite, in the state. The demand is almost certain to continue growing.

Midwifery in Pennsylvania

There are two different kinds of midwives: certified nurse midwives (CNMs) and midwives who do not seek education as nurses, whether due to the cost in time and money or because they’d prefer to avoid the institutional medical system. While CNMs are permitted to assist at home births in Pennsylvania, the regulations that attach to the practice make it uncommon. Almost all home births are assisted by non-nurse midwives.

The Midwife Regulation Law of 1929 was part of a nationwide professionalization and institutionalization of medicine, and specifically requires midwives to be licensed by a state board. However, the law has been enforced very infrequently over the years — only twice, according to one review — and some analysts have argued that the state implicitly permits uncertified midwifery.

Advertise with us

Even so, the 1929 law hangs like a Sword of Damocles over the state’s unlicensed midwives. Their lack of recognition in state law also freezes them out of the medical establishment, forcing them to develop workarounds, such as allying with a compliant physician who will prescribe basic medicines for their clients. It prevents them from getting malpractice insurance.

This makes their work riskier than it should be. In addition, the fear generated by their uncertain legal status, and their lack of malpractice insurance, can incentivize them to discourage their clients from seeking necessary care in order to cover their own possible mistakes.

Legitimizing an ancient practice

Even in this uncertain environment, home births assisted by unlicensed midwives remain generally safe and are growing in popularity. In response, most states have introduced a new license for non-nurse midwives that allows them to practice openly and without fear.

There are two accredited credentialing agencies for non-nurse midwives. The American Midwifery Certification Board offers the certified midwife (CM) credential, and the North American Registry of Midwives the certified professional midwife (CPM) credential. The first only credentials midwives who have completed a graduate-level degree in midwifery, while the second requires only a high school diploma or equivalent, plus an apprenticeship and demonstration of knowledge and skills. Twelve states license midwives with the CM credential, and 31 with the CPM credential.

Advertise with us

Licensed midwife deliveries are safe, increasingly popular and expand the freedom of Pennsylvania’s mothers to bring their children into the world the way they want to. Pennsylvania should accept either credential to be licensed to practice midwifery in the commonwealth. The new status would come with regulations to ensure the quality of care, something that’s lacking in the state’s current, uncertain legal environment. It would also allow these newly licensed midwives to be able to prescribe medicines and other procedures, such as ultrasounds.

Legitimizing more of the state’s midwives would also expand access to home births for people who currently can’t afford to pay out of pocket for unlicensed midwives. As the practice grows in popularity, it should not be available only to women with money to spare.

Over the last 12 years, at least 22 states have expanded their recognition of competent and knowledgeable non-nurse midwives. And in 2020, during the worst of the COVID pandemic, several Democratic state representatives, including Allegheny County Executive candidate Sara Innamorato, sponsored a bill to offer temporary licensure for existing CPMs in the commonwealth. There’s every reason to bring the issue back to the table, while making the licensure permanent.