Babies are our future, and that means our nation's future depends on every expectant mother having access to quality maternity care. Unfortunately, many hospitals, especially those in rural and poorer areas, lose money on obstetrics, and struggling hospitals are forced to limit the services they can provide or close their labor and delivery wards entirely.
While both the state and federal government must address dwindling access to all health care for rural Americans — and that includes raising already too low Medicaid reimbursement rates — they must make addressing maternity care deserts and a lack of providers more generally a top priority for legislation and public policy.
And they must support, again in legislation and public policy, an often-neglected resource. In solving this growing crisis, policymakers have an important asset at their disposal, at once ancient and modern: the practice of midwifery. As Pennsylvania loses more and more rural medical facilities, midwives can fill the gap.
Supporting legislation
Legislation at both the state and federal level should support midwife practice and education — and provide much needed practitioners to shore up the nation’s creaking system of maternal care.
The United States is an international outlier when it comes to maternal health, in at least two respects. First, outcomes for mothers and their babies are unusually poor when compared with those in other developed nations. Second, far fewer births are attended by midwives compared to other countries.
In the United Kingdom, for instance, about two in three births are attended by midwives. In other countries, like France and Spain, that figure is closer to three in four. In America, by contrast, midwives attend only one in eight.
Midwife care is associated with overall better health outcomes for both mother and baby, with significantly lower rates of emergency c-sections, episiotomies and preterm births. Taken together, the facts about outcomes and other nations’ standards of care expose American attitudes toward midwives, often considered heedless or amateurish, as uninformed — and, often, rooted in sexist assumptions about women’s abilities and wisdom.
Happily, these attitudes are changing: Over the past three decades or so, the share of midwife-attended births in the U.S. has doubled, to 12%. And in Pennsylvania, it’s now about 16%. That’s in part due to the Plain communities (Amish, Mennonite and so on) in the central part of the state, but it’s also due in part to growing midwifery programs within hospital systems, as well as freestanding birth centers like the Midwife Center for Birth & Women’s Health in the Strip District, one of the largest such facilities in the country.
While some certified nurse midwives work in a hospital, all must have have a collaboration agreement with a hospital physician in place, so they can seamlessly transport patients in case of an emergency complication. About 80% of pregnancies are considered “low-risk,” and therefore eligible for delivery in a birth center or, much less frequently, at home.
Midwives can fill the need
The number of maternity care deserts continues to grow. With the May closure of the maternity ward at Penn Highlands Elk, six northern Pennsylvania counties with 150,000 residents have no labor and delivery units. Outcomes for moms and babies decline significantly when care is over 90 minutes away from home.
In Harrisburg, a bipartisan effort has generated the Modernization of Midwifery in Pennsylvania proposal, known as Senate Bill 1262. Its prime sponsor is Monroe County Republican Sen. Rosemary Brown, and its co-sponsors include a dozen senators from across the ideological spectrum, including Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, and Minority Leader Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills.
The bill would liberate midwifery in several ways. First, as the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has previously supported, it would provide for licensure for certified midwives (CM) in addition to certified nurse midwives (CNM). CMs have all the same training in childbirth and women’s health as CNMs, without the additional nursing degree.
Licensure would regularize and regulate midwives currently practicing in the shadows, and would open a path for more people to enter the profession.
Sen. Brown’s proposal would also allow midwives to prescribe more medications, devices and therapies. Currently, midwives can prescribe for pain pills, but not for breast pumps, physical therapy to prepare for or recover from childbirth, or medications for postpartum depression. Crucially, the bill would also allow midwives to prescribe for medication-assisted treatment for opioid use disorder, a major issue especially in the urban and rural areas most likely to lack sufficient maternal care.
Advance modern midwifery
Altogether, the Modernization of Midwifery in Pennsylvania bill would allow midwives in general, and birth centers like the Midwife Center in particular, to fulfill their patients’ needs more completely and efficiently. In so doing, it would also make it more attractive to stand up new birth centers in maternity care deserts.
This won’t solve the broader economic problems in this area. A federal bill, the Midwives for MOMS Act, would help by providing $35 million (that’s between-the-cushions money in D.C.) in grants for midwifery education. Birth centers could also use start-up funding to clear their initial financial hurdles, as well as Medicaid reimbursement reform to ensure they’re being compensated fairly for the care they provide.
The United States may never transition to European-style maternity care, where midwives predominate and obstetricians mostly handle high-risk cases. But it can benefit from supporting and advancing the modern practice of midwifery, which offers better outcomes with less overhead, as the country grapples with the slow collapse of maternity care access, especially in rural communities.
Moms, and their babies, will be grateful. And with healthier mothers and children, America’s future will be improved. Support for midwifery is good for everyone.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.