Pennsylvania drivers can be charged with a DUI, regardless of demonstrated impairment, if marijuana is detected in their system. Some tests can detect marijuana that has been consumed in the last twelve hours; others, within a month of use. But none can confirm whether someone is under the effects of THC at any given moment.

Keystone State drivers who are obviously impaired should be ticketed, but arresting anyone with marijuana in his or her system can lead to widespread abuse. As a safeguard, state law should grant non-impaired drivers with medical marijuana licenses a shield from DUI charges. Even Pennsylvania State Police testified in favor of such legislation last year.

Rep. Chris Rabb, D-Philadelphia, and Rep. Aaron Kaufer, R-Luzerne, co-sponsored a bill in the state House that "would protect medical marijuana patients from being charged with DUI simply because drug tests show the presence of THC in their systems.”

Common sense supports this legislation. A so-called zero tolerance policy might have made sense when it was enacted, but that was before almost half-a-million registered medical marijuana users lived in Pennsylvania. Representatives Rabb and Kaufer noted in their memo that medicinal cannabis patients regularly contact their offices concerned that state law makes it illegal for them to drive.

Advertise with us

As the Post-Gazette’s John Finnerty reported, Pennsylvania is one of only a few states with zero tolerance for controlled substances. Thirty-three states, including those with no legal access to cannabis, require proof of actual impairment.

“Actual impairment” is what endangers drivers. People who use THC for sleep disorders will spend most working hours sober and driving responsibly — but they would still fail a drug test.

Until more sophisticated tests are developed, officers should rely on visible signs of impairment when charging licensed cannabis users. DUI charges on the basis of a positive test result should be reserved for those who are not enrolled in the state’s medical marijuana program.

Shield laws would help prevent the state from punishing responsible drivers who are getting the medical help they need.