At-large County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam has proposed increasing the minimum wage for government employees, including part-time and seasonal workers, to $20 an hour. This week, an amended version of Ms. Hallam’s plan, phasing in pay increases over three years, was approved by Council’s Government Reform Committee. Now, the plan must get the approval of the full Council and, if so, survive a probable veto by County Executive Rich Fitzgerald. Mr. Fitzgerald called the plan “fatally flawed” and onerous for taxpayers, possibly forcing a tax increase to pay for an extra $30 million.
Raising the minimum wage for county workers has considerable merit, though the amended version approved by committee is more prudent and fiscally responsible. It would raise the minimum wage to $18 an hour next year, then $19 in 2025, and $20 in 2026.
The federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour has stayed the same since 2009. Adjusted for inflation, workers earning the minimum wage today make 27.4% less than they would have in July 2009. Last year alone, the U.S. inflation rate, by some measures, exceeded 8%. Even before a recent spike in inflation, most economists considered $15 an hour a bare living wage. Congress has also focused efforts on raising the federal minimum to $15 an hour.
It would be unfair to say Mr. Fitzgerald’s objection were rooted in his personal animus toward Ms. Hallam, even though this tough, savvy and experienced politician can’t seem to say her name without hyperventilating. At least some of his objections, however, are not persuasive. His argument that raising the minimum wage would undermine the rights of unions to bargain their wages is especially weak.
The bill, as Ms. Hallam points out, would not bind current collective bargaining agreements. Instead, it would, like all minimum-wage laws, set a floor for future contracts. In principle, any government-established minimum wage, including the current state and federal minimum wage of $7.25 an hour, sets parameters for negotiations between employers and workers. A higher minimum wage protects all workers.
More than 30 unions represent county employees. Mr. Fitzgerald points out that full-time county employees will already make a minimum of $18 an hour as of next Jan. 1. But that undercuts, at least in part, the county executive’s argument that the proposed raise is excessive. Under the amended version, the minimum wage would increase to only $18 next year, anyway.
That said, Mr. Fitzgerald’s objections should be considered. Before approving the amended version, County Council should get its own legal opinion concerning whether the plan violates the county’s Home Rule Charter and state law. It also should get a firm and reliable estimate on what the amended plan would cost — and what those costs would mean for other county services and for tax bills.
Allegheny County, however, should at least try to set an example by paying workers wages they can actually live on.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.