An opinion by County Council Solicitor Frederick Frank raises further questions about whether the Allegheny County Jail is violating county ordinances that restrict solitary confinement and mandate more detailed reporting about its use. Getting answers, as well as recommendations for change, ought to be simple enough — but not in this county.
These legal questions and others, raised again by County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam this month, have lingered for more than a year, partly because of a lack of communication and cooperation between the County Jail administration and the Jail Oversight Board. Their dysfunctional and contentious relationship is interfering with the duties of both.
An audit by the National Commission on Correctional Health Care, released in March, also said the relationship between the two bodies needed immediate repair to ensure the jail runs efficiently, securely and safely for staff and inmates. Under state law, Jail Oversight Boards in every Pennsylvania county — including citizen members, judges, the county executive and other elected officials — should play a vital role in keeping local jails accountable to the public. In Allegheny County, however, the Oversight Board has been undercut by infighting and a hyper-adversarial relationship with the County Jail.
Some county officials attribute the problem to Ms. Hallam, who requested the opinion from Mr. Frank and said the county could get sued for not enforcing jail laws. A member of the Jail Oversight Board, Ms. Hallam has advocated for prisoners’ rights and sharply criticized the jail administration.
The NCCHC audit also singled out Ms. Hallam, without naming her, arguing that the “strained relationship” between the County Jail and Oversight Board “seems to be driven more by one member of the (Jail Oversight Board) than the process itself.”
In another oblique reference to Ms. Hallam, the NCCHC report urged open communication and transparency between the County Jail and Oversight Board to “counteract the negativity of the one board member who seems to be trying to drive a negative narrative about everything the (Allegheny County Jail) does.”
Pointing the finger
Placing all the blame on Ms. Hallam, however, is unfair. Communication is a two-way street; the jail’s defensive and recalcitrant warden, Orlando Harper, has made it difficult for the board to exercise its oversight function.
Moreover, Ms. Hallam’s critics should acknowledge that progress in the jail has resulted largely from public pressure — including pressure from Ms. Hallam.
She asks a lot of pesky questions, but that’s her job. Ms. Hallam can be relentless, vexatious, even crude, but she has brought attention to issues that would have been otherwise ignored, especially on health and mental health treatment in the jail, and the excessive use of segregation and probation detainers.
No doubt, alienating board members and jail administrators has made Ms. Hallam less effective. Still, her strident advocacy has been needed. With 17 prisoner deaths since April 2020, the jail reported one of the highest per-capita fatality rates in the country.
But the jail reported its last death seven months ago. After reviewing 27 prisoner deaths since January 2017, the NCCHC praised the jail’s suicide-prevention efforts. Allegheny County has reported only one suicide in the last three years, after eight between 2016 and 2019.
The jail population, at roughly 1,500, has gone down. In another encouraging sign, County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, understanding the compelling need for independent oversight, authorized in August the NCCHC review of jail deaths.
To become safer, more humane and more effective, the jail needs to operate under a culture of respect, competence, compassion and vigilance. Administrators, officers, medical staff and other employees must give a damn. There is some evidence, at least anecdotally, the jail’s culture is improving. If so, Warden Harper should get some credit for it.
Working together
Last month, jail administrators reported staff efforts to save a prisoner’s life. After the hospital sent the prisoner back to jail, staff identified drugs in his system and acted urgently to escalate his care and return him to the hospital. The key words here are “acted urgently.”
Further progress will depend largely on how well the Oversight Board and County Jail work together. They can start by responding to Mr. Frank’s legal opinion on segregation and reporting. If the jail has a problem, it should work with the Oversight Board to fix it — without pointing fingers. Too many lives are at stake for the dysfunctional and contentious relationship between the County Jail and its Oversight Board to continue.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.