The University of Pittsburgh demonstrated an admirable commitment to free speech by providing, and protecting, a forum on Tuesday for a conservative-libertarian debate on transgender rights. By contrast, in attempting to attack not only the debate participants but also the attendees, some protesters demonstrated an equal measure of ignorance.

To be sure, free speech includes protest, even disruptive protest. But lighting fires, menacing debate attendees and launching firecrackers at police officers is something else. Such actions reflect a dangerous and tyrannical intolerance that undermines a free society. Not even the most expansive definition of free speech under the First Amendment would apply to the melee Tuesday night. A democratic debate of ideas presupposes the ability to speak and listen with the intent to understand, not crush or overpower.

The protest

Prior to the event, a public debate focused on whether the university should host the event at all. Throughout the controversy, Pitt, rightly, didn’t back down from the idea that universities are bound to host such conversations about public policy and morality. That is their purpose, especially in a society with fewer and fewer opportunities to listen to, and exchange, vastly divergent opinions and ideas.

Advertise with us

All Americans are diminished whenever people going to a debate in this country need a police escort.

On Tuesday, debate attendees had to file into the O’Hara Student Center behind a line of university police officers. Protesters barred the door to the venue, as a smoke bomb flew into the line. Protesters started multiple fires, including burning debater Michael Knowles in effigy. Police officers were struck by firecrackers, but didn’t suffer serious injuries.

The protest also led to the unexpected closure of major arteries, perilously choking off access to some of the city’s largest hospitals. Ambulances had to divert to other facilities.

As the event began, an incendiary device exploded outside the hall. The building shuddered and the room when silent. After a brief delay, the debate went on, interrupted several times by shouting, before protestors were escorted out of the room.

As the protest continued outside, attendees had to wait more than 30 minutes for law enforcement to hustle them out the back door.

Advertise with us

The background

The debate had been planned for months by the Pitt College Republicans and the Intercollegiate Studies Institute, a conservative academic organization. The original participants were to be conservative commentator Mr. Knowles and transgender libertarian academic Deirdre McCloskey.

In a March 5, speech at the Conservative Political Action Conference, Mr. Knowles raised the temperature with this noxious statement: “For the good of society and especially for the good of the poor people who have fallen prey to this confusion, transgenderism must be eradicated from public life entirely.”

Thousands of people signed a petition asking the University of Pittsburgh to cancel the event. On March 11, Ms. McCloskey recommitted to the debate, tweeting, “A thousand people have signed a petition against Michael Knowles 'debating’ me on transgender matters on April 18 at Pittsburgh. They should be ashamed. True, Knowles is an anti-Jesus Catholic, a fascist advocating state power over ideas. But we live in a free country.”

Nevertheless, a few weeks later Ms. McCloskey dropped out. Event organizers secured Brad Polumbo, a libertarian commentator, to argue against government intervention in this culture war.

Advertise with us

The debate

Pitt’s commitment to a free exchange of ideas was appreciated by the audience of about 250, who gave the debaters and moderator an extended ovation. The applause didn’t reflect agreement with one or the other, but enthusiasm for the opportunity to listen and understand.

Unhappily, Mr. Knowles is a practiced provocateur whose antics are more likely to stoke rage than achieve mutual understanding. Over-the-top protests only burnish his brand. One attendee who came to see Mr. Knowles said the intensity of the protest left him even more committed to his views.

Incendiary devices, whether verbal or real, will simply make entrenched beliefs more rigid. Free speech doesn’t guarantee agreement — just the opposite. But it can help people examine their own beliefs and understand how others have come to a different conclusion. Without a tolerance for other ideas, no free society can endure.