After months of waffling, Mayor Ed Gainey is clearly taking Downtown safety seriously. The holistic public safety strategy he announced last Thursday in a letter to Downtown stakeholders addresses a range of issues, including violent crime and mental health. If executed, the plan will become a significant and effective investment in Downtown’s vibrancy.
Mr. Gainey’s Downtown safety proposal takes stakeholders’ concerns seriously, and employs public-private collaborations to engage the community. Tripling the number of city police officers Downtown grabbed the headlines, but more impressive is the plan’s prescriptions for underlying problems that don’t rely on law enforcement.
Helping rather than hiding
Chief among these alternative approaches to improving conditions Downtown is the “public safety ambassadors” program overseen by the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. Most behavior that bothers people downtown isn’t criminal, and shoving people out of sight won’t fix it. The ambassadors will address “non-criminal nuisances,” such as groups of rowdy teenagers or aggressive panhandling. People suffering from a mental illness will be referred to helpful social resources, not jailed.
Mr. Gainey’s plan also includes the Downtown expansion of violence reduction programs that are already active elsewhere in the city. The Golden Triangle is a neighborhood with more visitors than residents, and these programs will have to account for that. The key ingredient, especially for young people, will be to provide alternative activities while offering counseling, mental health services and staffing tailored to young people.
The committee to study city-run youth resource centers, launched last week by city council, is a good start. Its success, however, depends on the help of experienced leaders who have already launched effective after-school centers, like Caitlyn McNulty of Brookline Teen Outreach. Council should make sure they’re asked to join the committee.
Flooding the zone
Enhanced police presence should erode the sense of criminal impunity that seems to be growing Downtown, exemplified by a broad-daylight assassination in front of the Wood Street T Station on Jan. 19. Tripling the number of cops assigned to the central business district will be a tangible sign that the city will not allow Downtown to descend into chaos.
The city should also consider a regular mounted patrol Downtown. The majesty of the horses deters bad behavior while also providing a calming presence.
The mayor and Acting Police Chief Thomas Stangrecki must make good on their promise to vet officers for Downtown duty. They should meet particularly high standards for community relations, defusing tensions and relating to a diverse population. Pittsburgh does not need a battalion of cops descending on Downtown like an occupying army.
Mr. Gainey should also remain open to Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald’s offer to deploy county police officers Downtown. Robert Swartzwelder, president of the city’s police union, has threatened to file an unfair labor practices complaint if the mayor accepts help from outside the bargaining unit, but that shouldn’t deter Mr. Gainey. He should accept the help and let the courts settle any ensuing complaint.
A chance for leadership
The challenge to keep Downtown safe and vibrant will test Mr. Gainey’s leadership and political acumen. He was swept into office largely by the progressive wing of the Democratic Party, and has staffed his administration with many young activists and progressive political pros. His base of support is generally suspicious of law enforcement, and of the motives of merchants and suburbanites who bemoan the apparent decline of Downtown.
But Mr. Gainey is the mayor of all of Pittsburgh, including the developers, restaurateurs and property owners who need clients and office workers to not only be safe, but also feel safe. That means he must also consider the comfort of people who aren’t his constituents but contribute to the vitality of the Golden Triangle, such as commuters and evening visitors. Even if, as the mayor’s office has claimed, reported crimes Downtown have not risen significantly, insecurity about crime has certainly grown. Impressions can quickly become reality.
The plans announced last Thursday represent a sensible and collaborative approach that should ease the fears of Downtown stakeholders, while also meeting the demands of social justice. If everyone gets behind it and sees it through, the city may be approaching a turning point for Downtown.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.