Securing financial assistance for city government from Pittsburgh’s disproportionately weighty community of nonprofit medical and educational institutions has been a white whale for several successive mayoral administrations. Unfortunately, Mayor Ed Gainey’s opening salvo looks more like bluster than a promising line of attack.
Last Tuesday, Mr. Gainey announced that the city’s law and finance department will undertake an audit of every real estate parcel owned by nonprofit organizations, with the exception of religious groups, to ensure they are fulfilling the state’s definition of a “purely public charity.” Any pieces of property found to house operations oriented more to profit than to charity will then be brought onto the tax rolls.
In principle, it’s a clever stratagem. The best case for Mr. Gainey’s play is two-fold: First, by analyzing the nonprofits’ properties individually, he avoids taking on the behemoths as a whole — the mistake Mayor Luke Ravenstahl made. This will allow the city to focus its efforts on the operations arguably most distant from the organizations’ charitable mission, such as selling health insurance.
Second, the audit will allow Mr. Gainey to collect the evidence he needs to compete with the nonprofits during the inevitable litigation that will follow. This corrects another of Mr. Ravenstahl’s errors, which was to go into legal battle against a juggernaut with very few weapons at his disposal.
In practice, however, the audit will consume a tremendous amount of time and resources with no guarantee of success. Further, the greatest plausible success — after many years of litigation using up countless hours and millions of dollars’ worth of city employees’ time — will be to bring a small selection of nonprofit real estate onto the tax rolls. The audit appears designed to give the impression of fulfilling a campaign pledge to get tough on eds and meds nonprofits, without actually extracting anything from them.
The Post-Gazette’s Kris Mamula reports that there are 48,554 properties owned by tax-exempt organizations in Pittsburgh, each of which — except a certain number of parcels owned by religious organizations — will be studied by the city’s law and finance department. If 40,000 of those properties were subject to the audit and each received 15 minutes of attention, that would amount to 10,000 man-hours of work: 250 weeks for a single worker, or about a year for a team of five.
That will only get the city to the next step in the process: Referring any challenges to nonprofits’ tax status to the Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review. A panel of the board will make a decision on each challenge, then each decision can be appealed to the full board for a hearing. This part of the process could take several months or over a year, depending on the number of challenges and appeals.
Then either side can appeal the board’s decision to the state courts of appeals, beginning with Commonwealth Court and culminating in the Supreme Court. Each challenged parcel will likely be subject to its own litigation, meaning there could be dozens, hundreds or even thousands of cases moving through the court system. Some similar cases might be combined, but it will be in the nonprofits’ interest to make fine distinctions to ensure each property gets its own hearing, bleeding the city dry in the process.
In the end, the earliest the city could expect to receive a windfall, likely a very small one, is several years from now — almost certainly after Mr. Gainey’s term in office ends. If he is not reelected, a future mayor could even pull the plug on the whole thing.
UPMC, Highmark and others have the resources to see this litigation through. Does the City of Pittsburgh? Even if the city wins a few appeals, will the cost have been worth it? Is proving a point to UPMC worth the use of so many taxpayer-funded resources?
We don’t think so.
The better move for Mr. Gainey would be to return to the promising first days of his administration, when he stepped in to negotiate a fair compromise on the Oakland Crossings development and signaled that he would convene a roundtable of nonprofit leaders to negotiate payments-in-lieu-of-taxes (PILOTs). UPMC already make such payments in Altoona and Erie, so they can’t claim it’s an unprecedented proposal. And former Mayor Bill Peduto’s OnePGH fund, for all its flaws, showed that the nonprofits can be cajoled into writing big checks — UPMC notably pledged $40 million — for the common weal.
Boston’s voluntary PILOT system, which generated over $35 million in 2021, is another model to consider.
Mr. Gainey last year showed a preference — and an aptitude — for negotiation over confrontation and for thoughtful collaboration over vain grandstanding. That’s still the strategy most likely to secure payments from the city’s nonprofits for the services and infrastructure they depend on. The audit appears to be a long and winding road to nowhere.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.