Members of the Pennsylvania Senate have unanimously passed a long-overdue repeal of an antiquated statute barring teachers from wearing clothes or visible symbols that identify them with any religious group. The state House should quickly approve the repeal, and new governor Josh Shapiro should make signing it one of his first official acts.

To be sure, public school teachers shouldn’t teach, or argue for, their moral or religious viewpoints, or carry religious messages on their attire. Wearing clothes or accessories, however, that identify them with their religious traditions isn’t proselytizing or teaching.

Teachers bring their entire selves to their classrooms; they shouldn’t have to check an essential part of who they are at the door, whether they are Christian, Muslim, Jewish or adherents of any other faith.

The religious garb law, first passed in 1895 and renewed in 1949, ostensibly aimed to ensure a “religiously neutral” educational space. The history and application of the law, however, shows it has always targeted certain religious expressions considered unrespectable or unwelcome.

Advertise with us

The original 1895 law was not meant to keep public education purely secular, but purely Protestant. A year earlier, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court had ruled that, under then-current state law, a Catholic nun wearing her habit could teach in a public school, as long as she didn’t teach Catholic theology.

Seeing visible Catholics and a thriving Catholic education system as threats to public schools, outraged Pennsylvanians decided to change state law. Versions of the “religious garb” rule proliferated in dozens of states to keep nuns and other perceived threats out of public classrooms.

Successive generations found other targets for the laws. In central Pennsylvania at the turn of the twentieth century, plain-clothed Mennonite women were driven out of public schools for wearing head coverings. In Oregon, an application of that state’s garb law against a Sikh teacher was upheld by the that state’s Supreme Court in 1986. In 2014, a man who ran a group called “Jesus Was Not a Jew Ministries” tried to deploy Pennsylvania’s law against a teacher wearing a Star of David necklace.

In 2003, a federal court had ruled that applying the law against an Indiana County teacher wearing a simple cross necklace was unconstitutional. Even so, the now-neutered law has remained on the books.

Today, Pennsylvania is the only state with such a rule. It’s time to repeal this useless and oppressive vestige of a previous era.