Maternal and infant care is far more expensive in the United States than in other developed nations — and outcomes are worse. The U.S. system of pre- and post-partum care is broken. Making birth free to mothers and families would correct structural inequities and liberate women and families from financial coercion in a most intimate part of their lives.
The conversation was jumpstarted last week by a paper released by two anti-abortion groups: Americans United for Life and Democrats for Life of America. Their proposal to reduce the financial pressures to choose abortion through government support is refreshingly bi-partisan, with social conservatives embracing a solution typically linked to the left.
The plan would almost certainly reduce the number of abortions, without rolling back any state or federal rights to have one. Even most proponents of unrestricted abortion rights would agree that lowering the number of such procedures is worthwhile, and that financial coercion should not dictate the decision to have one. The costs of child bearing contributed to 75% of women’s decisions to seek an abortion, reports the Planned Parenthood-affiliated Guttmacher Institute.
The white paper estimates the cost of free births for all to be $40 billion per year. Other analysts, however, estimate the aggregate cost of non-Medicaid births at closer to $10 billion. In the world of federal budget expenditures, that’s not an overwhelming figure. As U.S. Sen. J.D. Vance, R.-Ohio, observed in commending the plan, the federal government found $100 billion — ten times that amount — to send to Ukraine last year.
The U.S. government is already subsidizing some reproductive choices. The Affordable Care Act mandates copay-free coverage for contraceptives, while simple care for pregnant mothers — blood tests, ultrasounds, and so on — can reach hundreds or even thousands of dollars.
As it stands, having a child is by far the most expensive reproductive choice a woman or family might make. The average cost of having a baby in America is $19,000, with typical out-of-pocket fees for privately insured mothers at $3,000 for the delivery alone.
From 2016 to 2019, one in six moms was on the hook for more than $5,000, while one in eleven families of newborn babies needing intensive medical care had to pay more than $10,000, reports the American Academy of Pediatrics.
Nor has the high cost of giving birth in America produced better health outcomes. In fact, the opposite is true. Among developed countries, the United States reports uncommonly high maternal and infant mortality rates. In 2020, 23.8 per 100,000 U.S. mothers died due to childbirth, nearly three time more than in Canada. The 5.4-per-1,000 infant mortality rate is 20% above our northern neighbor.
Maternal and neonatal care in America is broken, and the nation has the resources fix it. A solution offered by two anti-abortion groups provides plenty of common ground for people with vastly different views on abortion — if they have the courage and wisdom to see it.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.