Last year marked one of the biggest ever year-to-year increases in Pittsburgh homicides, which rose 39% to 71, up from 51 in 2021. With each of those 71 deaths, the highest in a decade, a piece of Pittsburgh died; a dream was snuffed out; precious human potential was wasted.

Other large cities have seen even steeper increases. In Philadelphia, which has topped 500 homicides in each of the last two years, crime and gun violence have become the city’s dominant political issue.

In Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, Black men have been most affected. Killings tend to concentrate in a small number of neighborhoods; they are committed by a comparatively small number of people. Still, the disease of violence has infected and influenced the entire region. For thousands of family members and friends, it has become deeply personal. It must become personal for the entire community.

Looking for leadership

Advertise with us

Because the causes of violence are complex and multi-dimensional, a rash of senseless killings can inure and overwhelm a community, making it feel helpless. Nothing could be more dangerous. Pittsburgh will never eliminate violence but, with intelligent actions and commitment, it can make 2023 far less lethal than 2022. Pittsburgh has the resources, dedication and energy to significantly reduce gun violence, despite a lack of leadership and focus at the top.

The Post-Gazette has been critical of Mayor Ed Gainey — perhaps too critical — for failing to sufficiently engage young people, as well as the people who live in, or at the margins, of the culture of violence. Mr. Gainey is a decent man and an evolving mayor. On this issue, however, he appears to be in over his head, and one man can’t solve the problem. His Plan for Peace correctly identifies violence as a public health problem but it reads more like an academic research paper than a community call-to-action.

It’s time to look elsewhere for leadership — to churches, non-profits, Pittsburgh’s powerhouse philanthropic foundations, young people and the people most affected by violence. In Pittsburgh’s poorest neighborhoods, almost every young person knows someone who was shot to death.

Foundations should step up  

Foundations such as the Heinz Endowments and Mellon Foundation have reshaped Pittsburgh’s cultural landscape, as well as supported education, the environment and other causes. Like the city’s cultural institutions, violence affects the community’s quality-of-life. Foundations should expand their missions by funding innovative, on-the-ground solutions to violence.

Advertise with us

Operation Peacemaker is one evidence-based model. Funded partly by foundations, it reduced homicides in Richmond, Calif., by more than 50% after launching in 2010. Before that, Richmond was rated one of the nation’s 10 most dangerous cities, with a per capita homicide rate nearly as high as Detroit’s.

Founder DeVone Boggan used street savvy staff members called Neighborhood Change Agents, most of them former prisoners, to identify and build relationships with the young men most likely to shoot or get shot. He called these potentially lethal young men to a meeting. Mr. Boggan knew tough talk wouldn’t work with people who don’t expect to live until their next birthday. They didn’t yet value their own lives, so they didn’t value the lives of others, either.

Instead, the Operation Peacemaker fellowship program offered them cash incentive to change their behavior. If they stayed out of trouble, attended meetings and participated in intense mentoring for six months, they would be eligible to earn as much as $1,000 a month for up to nine months. Neighborhood Change Agents also mediated potentially violent beefs on the streets. The program, costing roughly $20,000 per person, included travel and other incentives for finishing school, finding employment and achieving other goals.

Other programs also have proven effective, including Boston’s Operation Ceasefire and the Cure Violence community outreach program in Chicago. Instead of fearing or demonizing young men caught up in the culture of violence, they directly engaged them with people with similar experiences. By giving the small number of shooters another way to live and find self-respect, they made them part of the solution.

This week, Heinz Endowments named a new president, Chris DeCardy. The foundation distributed more than $90 million in grants last year. There could be no greater investment than funneling a sliver of that money into reducing the senseless loss of lives that continues to plague the city.