Tuesday night’s U.S. Senate debate in Harrisburg provided the best chance for voters to compare the policies and personalities of Democrat John Fetterman and Republican Mehmet Oz, in a forum that neither controlled. Increasingly, politicians are shutting out journalists, confining their campaigns to friendly rallies, Facebook live sessions, Twitter and other digital platforms. There, they can say anything without being challenged, checked or held accountable.
It’s a shame there was only one debate in this critical U.S. Senate race. That one debate took place two weeks before the election, after 500,000 people in Pennsylvania had already voted. For a high-profile race like this, candidates should debate at least twice — before early voting starts. Debates ought to inform as many voters as possible.
A single debate cannot cover even the most prominent issues. Pennsylvania’s opioid epidemic, which kills thousands of people a year, is getting increasingly deadly with fentanyl and fake pills. Even so, aside from a fleeting mention by Mr. Oz during a discussion of border security, Tuesday’s debate ignored opioid addiction, as well as the lack of treatment for it in jails and prisons.
To be sure, the debate was flawed. Both candidates ducked and dodged questions; both spent more time attacking each other than answering the questions. Moderators could have pressed a little harder to extract a straight answer. Still, the moderators — news anchors Dennis Owens and Lisa Sylvester — generally did a fine job of asking tough but fair questions, and following up when necessary. They showed why independent journalists are essential to covering political campaign and politicians.
Despite the debate’s shortcomings, enough of substance seeped through to make it worth watching, as well as make a convincing case for more debates.
Unhappily, voters will probably not see a debate between the candidates for governor: Democrat Josh Shapiro and Republican Doug Mastriano. Mr. Mastriano, who has avoided the mainstream media, said he wouldn’t debate Mr. Shapiro, unless the candidates could pick the moderators. Politicians like forums where they won’t be called out, questioned or held accountable for lies and misstatements.
Mr. Oz, a former surgeon and popular television host, had called for more debates, but members of the Fetterman campaign resisted, thinking debates would work against their candidate. Maybe they were right, but people understand Mr. Fetterman is recovering from a severe stroke he suffered in May. They expected the struggles Mr. Fetterman showed Tuesday night, with halting speech and occasional difficulties in getting words out and finishing sentences. (Mr. Fetterman continues to decline to release his medical records.)
Still, Mr. Fetterman’s condition could have worked to his advantage. He cast himself as a guy who was knocked down but keeps coming back. By contrast, Mr. Oz, clearly the more skilled debater, may have come off as too slick and smarmy.
Both men stumbled at times. In answering a question on abortion, Mr. Oz said he opposed any federal interference in abortion laws. He also said it should be a choice between a woman, her doctor and local politicians, a statement that Democrats jumped on immediately.
And Mr. Fetterman, when shown a statement he made in 2018 that opposed fracking, continued to insist he always favored fracking. Mr. Oz, who in 2014 expressed health concerns about fracking, also said he supported fracking.
Even their attacks might have made people aware of issues they knew nothing about. Mr. Oz asked Mr. Fetterman why he had not apologized to the Black man he allegedly pulled a shotgun on in 2013. Mr. Fetterman, then the mayor of Braddock, believed, wrongly, the man was fleeing from a crime. And Mr. Fetterman asked Mr. Oz why he promoted products made and sold in China.
Who won the debate? Pennsylvania voters who learned a little more about their two candidates for U.S. Senate. Too bad it was too little, too late.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.