When David Max Baer first ran for the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas in 1989, the Post-Gazette called the former deputy state attorney general a “more serious and accomplished lawyer than one might gather from his flamboyant advertising campaign.”

Mr. Baer’s judicial career more than lived up to the newspaper’s endorsement. His death leaves a legacy of integrity, and a gaping hole in Pennsylvania’s judiciary. The state Supreme Court’s Chief Justice died Friday at his home near Pittsburgh. He was 74.

As a judge, Mr. Baer married natural ebullience to seriousness of purpose. The “fighting judge” went by his middle name to evoke the celebrated 1930s boxer of the same name: His campaign featured an image of a bear wearing boxing gloves.

After his election to the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, Mr. Baer sought to make the court work better for people. He wasn’t content to coast through ten-year terms and often-perfunctory retention elections.

Advertise with us

The president judge assigned him to Family Court, generally considered an unpleasant commission, owing to its grueling pace and emotional proceedings. One bad decision could permanently scar a child, or taint a legal career. Still, Mr. Baer embraced the role, quickly rising to become the administrative judge of the court, a position that enabled him to reform the county’s Family Court system.

He streamlined the adjudication of cases and increased adoptions, resulting in a historic decline in the county’s foster care population. He also secured a $1.2 million grant to hire staff to pre-screen cases, enabling judges to make more informed and efficient decisions. He lobbied for a more spacious Family Court building that made an intimidating experience more bearable for the families summoned there.

In 1998, President Bill Clinton invited Mr. Baer to the White House to honor him for judicial innovation. In 2000, the Pennsylvania Bar Association named him the Pennsylvania Child Advocate of the Year.

The Post-Gazette endorsed his successful 2003 bid for the state Supreme Court. Mr. Baer made its proceedings more collegial and less contentious, becoming chief justice in 2021. At his death, he was three months from mandatory retirement at 75. Justice Debra Todd will accede to the role of chief justice, the first woman in the court’s 300-year history to do so.

There’s no rush to fill Mr. Baer’s vacancy on the Supreme Court. Whoever replaces him will not change the court’s balance. Democratic judges retain a 4-2 majority, and the absence of a seventh judge is unlikely to change the court’s decisions.

Justices are likely to be retained for multiple 10-year terms. With only a few days left in this year’s legislative session, rushing an appointment is imprudent. It’s best to let the next governor and Senate make a considered decision about who can fill the shoes — and the gloves — of “the fighting judge.”