The administration of Gov. Tom Wolf should drop its year-long fight to withhold statistics on medical marijuana use that have nothing to do with individual patients. In trying to keep the information secret, the state Department of Health has abused the law and set a poor example of open government for local municipalities, which already frequently violate state right-to-know and open-meetings laws.

The Department of Health has 30 days to appeal an order Friday by a panel of Commonwealth Court judges to show how many medical marijuana patients have received approvals from doctors to use cannabis for opioid addiction treatment. Fighting this order by petitioning the Pennsylvania Supreme Court would waste time and taxpayers’ money. The state’s legal arguments concerning confidentiality under the state’s medical marijuana law are unreasonably broad. The Department of Health should release the information now.

“The statute prevents access to whom, not to how many,” said Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel with the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association. “Information on how many is public.”

In June 2021, the media outlet Spotlight PA requested the number of medical marijuana certifications issued for each of the program’s 23 qualifying conditions. Aside from opioid use disorder, those conditions include anxiety disorders, epilepsy, cancer, Parkinson’s disease, HIV/AIDS and post-traumatic stress disorder.

Advertise with us

Hundreds of thousands of patients have medical marijuana cards to buy cannabis from dispensaries. Spotlight PA requested aggregate data — not individual names or information that violates patient confidentiality.  Even so, the state denied the request. Spotlight PA then appealed to the state Office of Open Records. In September, the Office of Open Records ordered the Department of Health to release the information, but the state ignored the order.

Spotlight PA seeks to illuminate how the medical marijuana program, using profitable but largely unregulated businesses, is working as a treatment option for opioid use disorder.  Pennsylvania legalized medical marijuana in 2016, but Spotlight PA has exposed problems with state oversight of the program.

Pennsylvania has some of the nation’s weakest, and most toothless, right-to-know and open-meetings laws. By refusing to release statistical information that would help the public evaluate a new program, the state has set a poor example of how a transparent government should work.

Kudos to Spotlight PA and the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. In Pennsylvania, the people get accountable and transparent government only when they demand it.