Politicians often love secrecy. They don’t want the public to know what happens in their offices or behind the scenes. Sometimes that’s reasonable. Important political deals get done only if both sides can bargain in secret. Sometimes public exposure would taint classified material and ruin military or intelligence plans that public exposure would ruin.
Those important political deals, however, might also be self-serving and harmful to the public good. Politicians often discuss classified material that shouldn’t be classified. And it’s clearly in the public interest to ruin some military or intelligence plans. Those dangerous plans will remain secret, however, unless journalists ferret them out, talk to insiders, or otherwise secure documents that aren’t public.
In other words, journalists need sources who leak.
Politicians and bureaucrats, of course, don’t like leaking or leakers. In Washington, Democrats and Republicans alike fear leakers. Presidential administrations, especially, want to expose leakers by seizing information from journalists, without their permission or even their knowledge.
President Barack Obama’s administration seized the records of the office, home, and cell lines of 20 AP reporters to track down their sources. This overbearing move, the New York Times editorial board rightly argued, went “beyond protecting government secrets to threatening fundamental freedoms of the press to gather news.”
President Joe Biden, in a perhaps unprecedented move for a sitting president, chose to stop this abuse of power by the government. At his direction, Attorney General Merrick Garland developed regulations to keep his department from seizing information and records from journalists. Such regulations recognized the “crucial role that a free and independent press plays in our democracy,” Mr. Garland said. Freedom of the press requires “freedom to investigate.”
The new regulation, with few exceptions, prohibit the Justice Department from taking, by force of law, the records of journalists and media members who are simply gathering the news and doing their jobs. The department may no longer force journalists to give up their sources or testify to grand juries.
The new regulations restrict this protection to legitimate journalists engaged in gathering the news; the Department of Justice may over-ride the rules in many circumstances, with permission from attorneys general or their assistant attorneys. And the new regulations don’t protect leakers, only the journalists they leak to.
But even leakers get additional protection from the regulations: At least they won’t be discovered because the government has seized a journalist’s phone records.
Journalists and the public should applaud the president for these new regulations. The freedoms they protect will strengthen democracy, a free press, and the entire society.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.